Kaelyn Moore

Lindley planned a date with Ben for the night so he wouldn't get suspicious.

That afternoon, she met up with Michael at the spa.

Both Lindley and Michael left their cell phones there with her co-worker Ashley.

Their cell activity and location histories gave them both alibis and made them look like they were there in Columbia, miles away at the time of the murder.

And then Lindley and Michael drove over to the farm to meet Ben that afternoon.

But at the last minute, allegedly Michael backed out.

He thought Lindley might regret it later, and he didn't want to be blamed for anything.

So according to Brandon, Lindley decided to do it herself, with Michael there for support.

So as Ben was cleaning the snake habitats along the back wall of the building, Lindley grabbed the gun from Michael's vehicle, walked in, and shot Ben eight times.

Michael picked up all the shell casings that he could see,

but clearly missed the ones that the EMT and coroner found.

Michael then drove Lindley back to the spa, where she showered, changed into clean clothes, and bagged her old ones for Michael to then destroy.

After that, Lindley went home and discovered Ben's body.

She then placed that 911 call at 6.36 p.m.

But this is all coming again from Brandon Blackwell.

This is just his side of the story.

And Lindley disputed all of this.

She claimed that he made it all up just to get out of jail.

So now investigators are sitting here questioning, who's telling us the truth?

Yeah, so investigators know they kind of have to take all of this with a grain of salt.