The Art of Industrial Coordination: Why We Can’t Quit Modbus

In this week’s deep dive on Coordinated with Fredrik, we tackled the $222 billion elephant in the room. That is the estimated amount manufacturers spend annually on maintenance caused by aging equipment.As engineering leaders, we face a brutal dilemma: How do we embrace Industry 4.0 and predictive analytics without ripping out the legacy systems that are actually keeping the lights on?. We hear so much about “digital transformation,” but in sectors like energy and water, reliability is everything3. You cannot just beta-test a substation.The answer isn’t to replace the past; it’s to coordinate it with the future.The “Operational Museum” and Trapped DataMost industrial environments are what I call “operational museums”. You have equipment from the 80s, 90s, and today, all trying to coexist. The biggest cost here isn’t just the spare parts; it’s the trapped data.We still see critical machine data confined to clipboards and paper logs. When data is entered manually hours later (or never), it becomes worthless for automation. You can’t build a predictive maintenance algorithm on data that is late or inaccurate.The 45-Year-Old Backbone: ModbusTo solve this, we went technically deep into the grandfather of industrial connectivity: Modbus.It was published in 1979 by Modicon. Why are we still talking about a protocol that predates the World Wide Web? Because it is royalty-free, ruthlessly simple, and it runs on everything.However, integrating Modbus is where the “coordination” headache begins:* The Architecture: It uses a Master-Slave architecture where slaves are passive—they only speak when spoken to.* The Addressing Trap: One of the biggest debugging time-sinks is the difference between the documentation (one-based indexing) and the actual message packet (zero-based addressing).* The Security Void: Modbus has zero native security. If you are on the network, you can read or write to any register.The Strategic Pivot: The GatewaySo, how do we bridge a 1979 protocol with 2025 AI analytics? We don’t rip out the machines. We invest in intelligent gateways.The strategy discussed in this episode involves using gateways to translate raw, local Modbus data into modern, IT-friendly protocols like MQTT or OPC UA.* OPC UA adds context and security, modeling the data so a register isn’t just a number, but a defined temperature value.* SunSpec standardization helps manage multi-vendor solar plants by ensuring registers are always in the same place.The Human FactorFinally, we can’t ignore the biological component of the system. Automation fails when the people on the floor reject it. We looked at a case study where foundry workers rejected a “cobot” because they saw it as a threat.Successful coordination means redefining the human role from “operator” to “supervisor and augmenter”The TakeawayDigital transformation isn’t a binary choice between old and new. It is an “and” strategy. By using gateways to coordinate legacy reliability with modern analytics, we can turn dormant data into immediate operational levers.Listen to the full episode to hear the technical breakdown of RS-485 best practices and why “daisy chaining” is non-negotiable. This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit frahlg.substack.com

There are no comments yet.

Please log in to write the first comment.