Adi Robertson

If you're talking about non-synthetic stuff, then there are all kinds of documentaries and news reports and really things that people have a public interest in making where you don't want to give someone the right to say you cannot depict me in a thing. And in that case, it's doing something I actually did. But AI-generated images raise the whole other question, which is, OK, so what –

If you're talking about non-synthetic stuff, then there are all kinds of documentaries and news reports and really things that people have a public interest in making where you don't want to give someone the right to say you cannot depict me in a thing. And in that case, it's doing something I actually did. But AI-generated images raise the whole other question, which is, OK, so what –

If you're talking about non-synthetic stuff, then there are all kinds of documentaries and news reports and really things that people have a public interest in making where you don't want to give someone the right to say you cannot depict me in a thing. And in that case, it's doing something I actually did. But AI-generated images raise the whole other question, which is, OK, so what –

Where do you draw the line between an AI-generated image and a Photoshop of someone and a drawing of someone? Should you not be able to depict any person in a situation that they don't want to be depicted in, even if that situation is something that would just broadly be protected by the First Amendment? Yeah.

Where do you draw the line between an AI-generated image and a Photoshop of someone and a drawing of someone? Should you not be able to depict any person in a situation that they don't want to be depicted in, even if that situation is something that would just broadly be protected by the First Amendment? Yeah.

Where do you draw the line between an AI-generated image and a Photoshop of someone and a drawing of someone? Should you not be able to depict any person in a situation that they don't want to be depicted in, even if that situation is something that would just broadly be protected by the First Amendment? Yeah.

Like, where do we think that the societal benefit of preventing a particular usage that hurts someone should be able to override the interest we have in just being able to write about or create images of someone?

Like, where do we think that the societal benefit of preventing a particular usage that hurts someone should be able to override the interest we have in just being able to write about or create images of someone?

Like, where do we think that the societal benefit of preventing a particular usage that hurts someone should be able to override the interest we have in just being able to write about or create images of someone?

The two bills are a little bit the thing I talked about where one of them, the Defiance Act, is really specifically about we want to look at non-consensual pornographic images. We define what that means. And we think that this particular thing we can carve out. There are lots of questions about, in general, how far you want to go in banning synthetic images. But it's really targeting porn.

The two bills are a little bit the thing I talked about where one of them, the Defiance Act, is really specifically about we want to look at non-consensual pornographic images. We define what that means. And we think that this particular thing we can carve out. There are lots of questions about, in general, how far you want to go in banning synthetic images. But it's really targeting porn.

The two bills are a little bit the thing I talked about where one of them, the Defiance Act, is really specifically about we want to look at non-consensual pornographic images. We define what that means. And we think that this particular thing we can carve out. There are lots of questions about, in general, how far you want to go in banning synthetic images. But it's really targeting porn.

sexually explicit pictures of real people. And I think things like the No Fakes Act, I believe there's also something called the No AI Fraud Act. These are much broader. We just think that you shouldn't be able to fake images of people. And we're going to make some carve-outs there, but the fundamental idea is that we want to create a giant federal likeness law.

sexually explicit pictures of real people. And I think things like the No Fakes Act, I believe there's also something called the No AI Fraud Act. These are much broader. We just think that you shouldn't be able to fake images of people. And we're going to make some carve-outs there, but the fundamental idea is that we want to create a giant federal likeness law.

sexually explicit pictures of real people. And I think things like the No Fakes Act, I believe there's also something called the No AI Fraud Act. These are much broader. We just think that you shouldn't be able to fake images of people. And we're going to make some carve-outs there, but the fundamental idea is that we want to create a giant federal likeness law.

And I think that's much riskier because that is much more a, we start from a point of saying that you shouldn't be able to fake an image of someone without their permission. And then we're going to create some opt-ins with some options where you're allowed to do it.

And I think that's much riskier because that is much more a, we start from a point of saying that you shouldn't be able to fake an image of someone without their permission. And then we're going to create some opt-ins with some options where you're allowed to do it.

And I think that's much riskier because that is much more a, we start from a point of saying that you shouldn't be able to fake an image of someone without their permission. And then we're going to create some opt-ins with some options where you're allowed to do it.

And I think that raises so many more of these questions that do we really want to create a federal ban on being able to create a fictionalized image of somebody?

And I think that raises so many more of these questions that do we really want to create a federal ban on being able to create a fictionalized image of somebody?