Advertisement Narrator

Who wouldn't be?

I'll speak for myself here. I can safely say Sue Mosley is a better person than me. And I think you'd be hard-pressed to find many people willing to extend forgiveness for being defrauded, manipulated, and robbed in their golden years. Her son Jim told me that was his mom through and through.

I'll speak for myself here. I can safely say Sue Mosley is a better person than me. And I think you'd be hard-pressed to find many people willing to extend forgiveness for being defrauded, manipulated, and robbed in their golden years. Her son Jim told me that was his mom through and through.

I'll speak for myself here. I can safely say Sue Mosley is a better person than me. And I think you'd be hard-pressed to find many people willing to extend forgiveness for being defrauded, manipulated, and robbed in their golden years. Her son Jim told me that was his mom through and through.

It was an outstanding act of grace, significant to all but one person in the room that day.

It was an outstanding act of grace, significant to all but one person in the room that day.

It was an outstanding act of grace, significant to all but one person in the room that day.

She was cunning and brazen when she needed attention from someone else, but cowardly when someone demanded her attention. While Sandra may not have paid Sue's forgiveness any mind, Judge James Dever III sure did. In cases of nonviolent crimes, acts of grace can actually influence sentencing outcomes. The gavel fell.

She was cunning and brazen when she needed attention from someone else, but cowardly when someone demanded her attention. While Sandra may not have paid Sue's forgiveness any mind, Judge James Dever III sure did. In cases of nonviolent crimes, acts of grace can actually influence sentencing outcomes. The gavel fell.

She was cunning and brazen when she needed attention from someone else, but cowardly when someone demanded her attention. While Sandra may not have paid Sue's forgiveness any mind, Judge James Dever III sure did. In cases of nonviolent crimes, acts of grace can actually influence sentencing outcomes. The gavel fell.

Officially charged with one count of identity theft, Sandra was sentenced to the mandatory minimum term of two years in prison. She'd have one year of supervised release. By then, it was anyone's guess whether she still had the nerve or the audacity to pull another con on an unsuspecting family.

Officially charged with one count of identity theft, Sandra was sentenced to the mandatory minimum term of two years in prison. She'd have one year of supervised release. By then, it was anyone's guess whether she still had the nerve or the audacity to pull another con on an unsuspecting family.

Officially charged with one count of identity theft, Sandra was sentenced to the mandatory minimum term of two years in prison. She'd have one year of supervised release. By then, it was anyone's guess whether she still had the nerve or the audacity to pull another con on an unsuspecting family.

The more I think about Sandra's whole story, the more I find myself circling the same two opposing questions. Did she outthink law enforcement at every turn? Or did cops make mistakes and let her slip away when they should have had her dead to rights? In the final weeks of production on this podcast, I was mulling this over with PI Carrie Huskinson. This is what she said.

The more I think about Sandra's whole story, the more I find myself circling the same two opposing questions. Did she outthink law enforcement at every turn? Or did cops make mistakes and let her slip away when they should have had her dead to rights? In the final weeks of production on this podcast, I was mulling this over with PI Carrie Huskinson. This is what she said.

The more I think about Sandra's whole story, the more I find myself circling the same two opposing questions. Did she outthink law enforcement at every turn? Or did cops make mistakes and let her slip away when they should have had her dead to rights? In the final weeks of production on this podcast, I was mulling this over with PI Carrie Huskinson. This is what she said.

From Sony Music Entertainment, you're listening to the finale of Fatal Beauty. I'm Cooper Maul. Episode 6, Hard to Get. It turned out a cold case investigator in Oklahoma City already had Sandra in his sights from the moment of her capture. His name is Kyle Eastridge. When news of her arrest made headlines...

From Sony Music Entertainment, you're listening to the finale of Fatal Beauty. I'm Cooper Maul. Episode 6, Hard to Get. It turned out a cold case investigator in Oklahoma City already had Sandra in his sights from the moment of her capture. His name is Kyle Eastridge. When news of her arrest made headlines...

From Sony Music Entertainment, you're listening to the finale of Fatal Beauty. I'm Cooper Maul. Episode 6, Hard to Get. It turned out a cold case investigator in Oklahoma City already had Sandra in his sights from the moment of her capture. His name is Kyle Eastridge. When news of her arrest made headlines...

Detective Eastridge is retired now, but he used to be a homicide detective and eventually cold cases became his focus. After retiring, Eastridge was diagnosed with ALS. In our conversations, I never got a sense it kept him down. The guy's got a mean sense of humor and an encyclopedic knowledge of homicide investigations.