Menu
Sign In Search Podcasts Charts People & Topics Add Podcast API Blog Pricing

Andrea Dumlop

๐Ÿ‘ค Speaker
217 total appearances

Appearances Over Time

Podcast Appearances

Nobody Should Believe Me
Revisiting Kowalski Part Two: The Descent

Beata signs her email XOXO.

Nobody Should Believe Me
Revisiting Kowalski Part Two: The Descent

As he appears to do with many of his patients, Dr. Kirkpatrick recorded videos of his evaluations of Maya.

Nobody Should Believe Me
Revisiting Kowalski Part Two: The Descent

And these are frankly strange to watch.

Nobody Should Believe Me
Revisiting Kowalski Part Two: The Descent

As we discussed in the last episode, Maya's alleged condition, complex regional pain syndrome, is, well, regional.

Nobody Should Believe Me
Revisiting Kowalski Part Two: The Descent

And it's a condition that begins with some kind of injury.

Nobody Should Believe Me
Revisiting Kowalski Part Two: The Descent

Yet in Dr. Kirkpatrick's evaluation of a wheelchair-bound Maya, he's asking her about pain everywhere, from her cheeks to her shoulders to her feet and the skin on the top of her thigh.

Nobody Should Believe Me
Revisiting Kowalski Part Two: The Descent

Reading Dr. Kirkpatrick's depositions and watching his testimony, it's tough to wrap your brain around how he justifies giving Maya this diagnosis, which he describes as severe and progressive in her case.

Nobody Should Believe Me
Revisiting Kowalski Part Two: The Descent

He says in a deposition that while CRPS is usually triggered by an injury, that quote, often we don't know what causes it in children because they're quote, not good record keepers on account of how much they're quote, bouncing around.

Nobody Should Believe Me
Revisiting Kowalski Part Two: The Descent

Which, sure, they are, but as a mom of a seven-year-old and a three-year-old, I can tell you that children are not especially stoic when they hurt themselves.

Nobody Should Believe Me
Revisiting Kowalski Part Two: The Descent

It is, in fact, usually an entire opera.

Nobody Should Believe Me
Revisiting Kowalski Part Two: The Descent

Anyway, according to Beata, Maya's CRPS symptoms allegedly began with an asthma attack.

Nobody Should Believe Me
Revisiting Kowalski Part Two: The Descent

which even Kirkpatrick says there's no known connection with.

Nobody Should Believe Me
Revisiting Kowalski Part Two: The Descent

And yet right away, in the first appointment, Beata gets the CRPS diagnosis she's been looking for, and they're off to their races scheduling a four-day-long ketamine infusion.

Nobody Should Believe Me
Revisiting Kowalski Part Two: The Descent

Here, Beata asks Dr. Kirkpatrick about the side effects.

Nobody Should Believe Me
Revisiting Kowalski Part Two: The Descent

Now, it's not unheard of to use ketamine in treating CRPS, as Dr. Elliot Crane, the pediatric pain specialist we heard from in the last episode, explains on the stand.

Nobody Should Believe Me
Revisiting Kowalski Part Two: The Descent

However, Dr. Crane emphasized that ketamine is used as a last resort for refractory pain or pain that won't resolve any other way and is used at a very low dose.

Nobody Should Believe Me
Revisiting Kowalski Part Two: The Descent

So it's possible that a child with CRPS might need to receive some type of ketamine treatment at some point.

Nobody Should Believe Me
Revisiting Kowalski Part Two: The Descent

However, as a reminder, three hospitals, Johns Hopkins All Children's, Lurie's Children's in Chicago and Tampa General had all evaluated Maya and determined that she was suffering from a conversion disorder.

Nobody Should Believe Me
Revisiting Kowalski Part Two: The Descent

And interestingly, the standard of care for conversion disorder is the same as that for CRPS, physical and occupational therapy and psychotherapy.

Nobody Should Believe Me
Revisiting Kowalski Part Two: The Descent

But that was not Dr. Kirkpatrick's way of doing things.