Menu
Sign In Search Podcasts Libraries Charts People & Topics Add Podcast API Blog Pricing

Andrea Vance

πŸ‘€ Speaker
66 total appearances

Appearances Over Time

Podcast Appearances

The Detail
The 'toothless' law keeping us in the dark

Those media requests, say we're talking about a government department, you can give them a deadline.

The Detail
The 'toothless' law keeping us in the dark

Often you'll say end of the day.

The Detail
The 'toothless' law keeping us in the dark

And by and large, they will get back to you by that deadline.

The Detail
The 'toothless' law keeping us in the dark

But occasionally the information that you're requesting

The Detail
The 'toothless' law keeping us in the dark

we'll need some kind of coalition.

The Detail
The 'toothless' law keeping us in the dark

It'll take longer to pull together.

The Detail
The 'toothless' law keeping us in the dark

For example, at the weekend, I wrote a story about lobbying in the issue of climate change weather events and slash debris.

The Detail
The 'toothless' law keeping us in the dark

And so there was about 29 submissions that came into the Ministry for Environment, and often they have to go to the submitters and ask if they're all right to release that information.

The Detail
The 'toothless' law keeping us in the dark

So

The Detail
The 'toothless' law keeping us in the dark

There are ones that can be answered quickly by media, and then there are other ones that follow the standard OAA process.

The Detail
The 'toothless' law keeping us in the dark

It takes about 20, well, usually more than 20 days, but a minimum of 20 working days.

The Detail
The 'toothless' law keeping us in the dark

it would be very rare for you to get an OIA where no information is redacted.

The Detail
The 'toothless' law keeping us in the dark

And sometimes it can be something as simple as redacting the email address or telephone number of someone mentioned in the document.

The Detail
The 'toothless' law keeping us in the dark

But sometimes the information in the document is out of scope of your request.

The Detail
The 'toothless' law keeping us in the dark

It doesn't relate to what you're asking.

The Detail
The 'toothless' law keeping us in the dark

Some redactions are entirely legitimate.

The Detail
The 'toothless' law keeping us in the dark

So for privacy, commercial sensitivity, although that one is debatable, legal privilege or national security over the maintenance of law.

The Detail
The 'toothless' law keeping us in the dark

Others can be more debatable.

The Detail
The 'toothless' law keeping us in the dark

And one of the biggest challenges for journalists is not the blackout text, but understanding what has been removed and why.

The Detail
The 'toothless' law keeping us in the dark

Sometimes the missing paragraph is obvious from the context.