Annie Elise

The first theory that comes to mind in John's death is a robbery, which I'm sure that he would have had plenty of things of value in his home.

But the thing was, there were no signs of forced entry and no signs of any kind of robbery.

John's murder seemed like it had been more personal, more targeted.

And John did have some secrets that he had been hiding that ended up coming to light after his death.

Multiple sources came out saying that he had been having an affair with a woman who is referred to in the media as Mistress Y. She was one of the last people to speak with him before he was killed.

And it's important to mention that John's wife had died from cancer a month before his death.

So I'm not sure if the affair that he was having with Mistress Y began way before his wife's death or after making it, you know, not really an affair then.

But either way, he did have a woman who he was seeing and was keeping a secret from his family.

And this woman was technically the last person to have spoken with John, though it wasn't in person, just over the phone.

Apparently, it was discovered that the weekend before John's murder, the two of them had gone on a private little getaway to the Mohegan Sun Casino.

He gave her a little bit of cash to blow at the casino or, you know, just play around with and have almost like a sugar daddy situation.

And I'm sure a lot of the money was simply just for spending time with him.

I'm just going to call it what it was, maybe even to in exchange for companionship or whatever else, you know, rolls into that equation.

But

Nathan's lawyers would later argue that Mistress Y knew that John was loaded and that he would constantly just hand over money to her, which gave her plenty of motive to kill him, which sort of makes sense but also sort of doesn't.

If she thinks that he's getting older and she's going to be in the will and she's going to get this huge inheritance, I get where that makes sense.

But then if she's not in the will, you basically would be killing off your sugar daddy and all of your money privileges, which that doesn't make a whole lot of sense.

I'm not sure where the motive is and how real that is, if I'm being honest.

And a lot of people were confused about it, but personal opinions aside, the investigators cleared her pretty quickly.

I'm not even sure, to be honest, what her alibi was.