Annie Elise

One of the callers was the woman who pulled the trigger and shot AJ.

Now, if you haven't heard about this case yet, just based on the 911 calls and everything so far, you might be thinking to yourself, okay, it sounds like maybe it was some sort of dispute between neighbors.

Maybe even something more severe like a potential break-in, vandalism, something like that.

Well, the story that the caller tried to tell that night...

isn't even close to what really happened.

The woman on that 911 call was 58-year-old Susan Loritz.

She had made it sound like somebody had been trying to hurt her or was somebody trying to get inside her home.

But as you will come to learn very quickly in today's episode, this case is not straightforward.

And it isn't at all what it appears to be on the surface.

Now, you might be familiar with this case if you watched the recent documentary, The Perfect Neighbor.

But...

That documentary, while very, very incredibly well done and moving, it consisted primarily of body cam footage, not the story and the details behind everything.

And that's why I wanted to cover this episode today.

I want to not only give you some of that footage and those sound bites, but I want to explain the story to you as well, just so that you have full context.

Now, if you have not watched The Perfect Neighbor yet, I do want to warn you, for me personally, I watched it before we researched this case and dug into it more.

And at one point, and I'm not going to say what point in case you have not seen it, at one point in the middle, I had to stop watching.

I ended up finishing it because I knew I needed to, but it is a very difficult watch because, again, so much of it consists of the actual firsthand account from the body cam footage.

So today, like I said, I want to just break down this story for you and the reality of everything and all of the parts that weren't left in because they didn't really give narrative at all in this documentary.

and explain the truth.

Because something horrific happened that night between these two neighbors.