The Bookshelf
On Tara June Winch's The Yield, Tony Birch's The White Girl and Julia Phillips' Disappearing Earth
And it also was, it was that lovely thing that what is at the heart of fiction is that we are a storytelling people.
The Bookshelf
On Tara June Winch's The Yield, Tony Birch's The White Girl and Julia Phillips' Disappearing Earth
And when there's a void where we don't know the answers to something, competing stories try to fill that space and become that.
The Bookshelf
On Tara June Winch's The Yield, Tony Birch's The White Girl and Julia Phillips' Disappearing Earth
And some of the characters were so convinced by their story that we knew was absolutely wrong, but they were so convincing in the telling of it that you could see how plausible it sounded to basically send off the investigation into a whole wrong direction.
The Bookshelf
On Tara June Winch's The Yield, Tony Birch's The White Girl and Julia Phillips' Disappearing Earth
And at the same time, she had a beautiful parallel with a missing Indigenous girl who had disappeared three years earlier.
The Bookshelf
On Tara June Winch's The Yield, Tony Birch's The White Girl and Julia Phillips' Disappearing Earth
Lilia.
The Bookshelf
On Tara June Winch's The Yield, Tony Birch's The White Girl and Julia Phillips' Disappearing Earth
And the stories that are being built up around her and the different ways they were being treated.
The Bookshelf
On Tara June Winch's The Yield, Tony Birch's The White Girl and Julia Phillips' Disappearing Earth
Was this a racial difference that we don't care about Indigenous girls missing?
The Bookshelf
On Tara June Winch's The Yield, Tony Birch's The White Girl and Julia Phillips' Disappearing Earth
Or was it difference because of the ages involved?
The Bookshelf
On Tara June Winch's The Yield, Tony Birch's The White Girl and Julia Phillips' Disappearing Earth
Lilia is much older.
The Bookshelf
On Tara June Winch's The Yield, Tony Birch's The White Girl and Julia Phillips' Disappearing Earth
She's late teens.
The Bookshelf
On Tara June Winch's The Yield, Tony Birch's The White Girl and Julia Phillips' Disappearing Earth
There's a question of, did she run away?
The Bookshelf
On Tara June Winch's The Yield, Tony Birch's The White Girl and Julia Phillips' Disappearing Earth
Whereas these two Russian girls, one of the Indigenous people sort of says it's as if they invented disappearing.
The Bookshelf
On Tara June Winch's The Yield, Tony Birch's The White Girl and Julia Phillips' Disappearing Earth
We're getting so much attention of these two young girls when this is happening to Indigenous people and no one's paying attention.
The Bookshelf
On Tara June Winch's The Yield, Tony Birch's The White Girl and Julia Phillips' Disappearing Earth
And that's a story that, I mean, we've seen in this country and, you know, in other countries too, of this difference of treatment.
The Bookshelf
On Tara June Winch's The Yield, Tony Birch's The White Girl and Julia Phillips' Disappearing Earth
And I think she does that so perfectly in this book.
The Bookshelf
On Tara June Winch's The Yield, Tony Birch's The White Girl and Julia Phillips' Disappearing Earth
It's really beautifully done.
The Bookshelf
On Tara June Winch's The Yield, Tony Birch's The White Girl and Julia Phillips' Disappearing Earth
So much of fiction is trying to put order in the chaos, but in a way, because of her structure, she sort of has embraced the chaos of what does fate have in store for us, that something can come in and just totally knock your life sideways, that you've got no control of, and yet all we want to do the whole time is feel like we're in control.
The Bookshelf
On Tara June Winch's The Yield, Tony Birch's The White Girl and Julia Phillips' Disappearing Earth
And so for a lot of this book, she allows those characters to have those moments where everything turns around and you think, how do I cope?
The Bookshelf
On Tara June Winch's The Yield, Tony Birch's The White Girl and Julia Phillips' Disappearing Earth
And I love that, that sometimes you would meet a character in one story.
The Bookshelf
On Tara June Winch's The Yield, Tony Birch's The White Girl and Julia Phillips' Disappearing Earth
And, for example, the story of the young Indigenous woman who's gone to the city to study at university and is sort of having a bit of a moment of crisis.