Ash Kelley

Because I personally wouldn't do that, but I can at least try to wrap my brain around it.

it be historically accurate historically accurate having that be his past and having that be part of him becoming what he is today yep that's the thing though make him grow yeah there's no and i don't when he's sitting there being like hell yeah like i was youngest major in the texas calvary it's like

Fuck.

You're just like, I don't know about that.

I just don't know about that.

It's not good.

So that was weird.

I thought that was a whole weird thing.

Another backstory, though, that gets revealed is Rosalie's.

Rosalie's.

And this I have a lot to say about.

Rosalie's is awful.

But I love her fucking revenge arc.

I absolutely love her revenge arc.

I don't think we got enough of it.

No, I don't think we did either.

I wish that this was rated R so that I could watch her slaughter all of those men.

Oh, it would have been sick.

I wish.

Oh, one thing I noticed in the book, and I forgot about this, Rosalie is far more palatable in the book to Bella.