Ash Kelley

More importantly, he didn't believe in witchcraft or the trickster gods, so he didn't have any of the confidence and the smug cockiness that kept the others from talking.

He said, I know I'm not invisible.

He said, I know you can see me right here, right now.

Basically, he would be easy to break.

Just easy to get information out of.

So it turned out that Benitez's assessment of the caretaker was right.

Within just a few minutes of the interrogation, he was telling agents everything he knew.

Oh.

Yeah.

He began to say something about an American who he had seen at the ranch recently, and then he kind of trailed off, almost seeming to realize that he said something he shouldn't have.

So the other agents and Benitez were aware of the disappearance of Mark Kilroy, and several of them had been involved in the case on the Mexican side, but it wasn't until that moment that they all assumed the case they were working on was a separate matter entirely.

Oh, shit.

They had thought that, and then they were like, oh, this is... Damn.

This is not...

Oh.

Oh.

The men at the ranch had left him tied up like that in the truck overnight.

Domingo said, Oh my God.

This like makes my stomach hurt.

It's horrific.