Ashley Flowers

And then one street west of the park is where Alberta's car is ultimately found.

Arthur just keeps saying, I was a good kid.

I didn't hurt anybody.

I didn't hang around with anybody who did.

And he's even willing to take a polygraph to prove it.

So they're like, perfect.

Let's get this on the books for the next day.

And they do.

And Arthur shows up as promised for it.

And he fails.

In fact, the report found, quote, the highest level of deception possible.

I think 2008 detectives probably thought they had their man.

Or at least they found a man with the answers that they were looking for.

But they could not get Arthur to talk after that.

Yeah, but like not knowing where the prints are from leaves this door open to a million explanations.

So even though they, it seems like, want to charge Arthur with something, the Kentucky Commonwealth attorney refuses.

In a letter that they sent to the Louisville Metro Police Department, it says that the state would not prosecute Arthur then or ever because the case wouldn't hold up in court.

Well, I thought it was really interesting that Arthur mentioned two friends that he was with a lot that summer.

Because I was thinking about that gas station sighting of Alberta.

There were three teens.