Beth Maxwell

What was it about Marty that caught your eye? He didn't judge me, like, because I'm a bigger girl, so, you know, it's something that I get judged for a lot. He just accepted me for who I was. The polite man she met online seemed like a true gentleman in person. He just was a charmer, kind of. He was what I wanted, what I've always wanted. He opened the car door for me.

He was the dad that I've always wanted my son to have.

Yeah, it was. And my son picked up on it right away, too. He's like, that's my Marty dad. That's what he called him.

We were like, why wait? Like, if that's what we feel, why not just go for it? It all seemed too good to be true.

Yes.

It didn't sit great with me. Beth met Paige for the first time on their wedding day. She wanted to dress exactly like Marty. It was a big fight. She seemed very controlling, like this is what she wanted done, so he had to do it her way.

including her. I found out that he had bought her a car, was paying her rent. Had he bought you a car? No, he never bought me a car. He bought her food a lot of times.

Like groceries and stuff, yeah.

And that he had feelings for her. Yeah, definitely. I started really having issues with it because I'm like, why is the best friend getting treated better than the wife? In fact, one of Beth's friends told her Paige had bragged about her power over Marty. She actually told my best friend that she could steal Marty away.

He was just that obsessed over her and there was just no changing it. I don't know.

And there's six to seven people at my door. Police officers. Police officers, yeah. Detectives.