Blayne Alexander

We've been looking for Jay Lee's body for two years, and we're not going to stop until we find him.

And I can guarantee you that.

But they had not found him, and therefore, Horan told the jury, the prosecution had not proven its case.

The case was headed to the jury and the court was in for a surprise.

How did you find out what had happened?

It seemed so simple to the people who loved Jay Lee.

He was clearly dead and Tim Harrington most certainly killed him.

So as the case went to the jury, Jay's sister was counting on a quick verdict.

And they go back and they're deliberating.

How are you feeling?

I was feeling very confident.

When I tell you my confidence was up the roof, I felt like I was Jay that day.

But the jury had to weigh all the evidence, and the defense had argued there was no blood, no DNA or fibers, not even a body that linked Harrington to murder.

After four hours, the jury sent a note to the judge.

We have a note from the jury that says we feel confident we are unable to reach a unanimous decision.

They were deadlocked.

He encouraged them to dig a little deeper.

I'm going to send you back.

I was like, okay, what in the...

World is going on.