Brandon Kyle Goodman

So she threw that in there, or who knows where she is.

Is that fair to say, or did you take it the same?

It seemed like there was significant back and forth, like we were getting somewhere with the person who was sending the notes to TMZ.

I mean, we could only hope that she has some information that maybe she knows and we don't, that there is some validity or credibility to the person writing those notes to TMZ saying, I will give up the person who took Nancy Guthrie if I get $50,000 now and $50,000 later.

So maybe there is, and that would be amazing if that is true.

But I also think...

Any crime that's ever been committed, especially of this magnitude, it's rarely done without someone else knowing.

Someone else who that person came home to, who that person acted bizarrely in front of, who had some clothes to clean or some... You always hear about this after the fact.

Sometimes these folks either have roommates, loved ones, best friends.

Sometimes they confide.

It would be hard to believe that someone else...

close to or around the person who took Nancy Guthrie doesn't know or isn't thinking something's off.

And the other point connected to that, Rose, is that most criminals aren't this good at covering their tracks.

They're just not.

So that would lend itself to your theory.

Somebody knows who this guy is.

Somebody has to know, and maybe that's the way to go, to appeal to the humanity of someone around this person rather than this person.

That is a very good point.

It seems so improbable, Rogues, that nobody noticed this guy being gone overnight from his own home.

He was acting strangely the next day or something.