Menu
Sign In Search Podcasts Charts People & Topics Add Podcast API Blog Pricing

Carl Robichaud

๐Ÿ‘ค Speaker
617 total appearances

Appearances Over Time

Podcast Appearances

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

My concern is that

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

All of the processing of the information and the interpretation of the information could be done by an AI system in a way that leaves humans essentially as button pushers.

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

Are you really going to...

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

reject the conclusions of a system that has proved 99% reliable and that's built on state-of-the-art software and hardware.

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

And it just really seems to be the best way to support your decisions.

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

And that's, I think, the slippery slope we might go on.

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

And there are some efforts in Congress to limit that.

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

I think that

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

As with other command and control issues, we are only as safe and secure as the weakest link in the chain.

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

And so we need to be getting together now with Russia, China, other countries to figure out how can we avoid this slippery slope in which we are essentially delegating nuclear decisions to an algorithm, because that's a really scary world.

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

I mean, I think you've put your finger on it, which is that these digital systems and these human systems are prone to different modes of failure.

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

And the problem fundamentally is making high-stakes decisions

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

under incredible time pressure.

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

That's the fundamental problem, and that's what I think we need to move back from.

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

We need to devise a system that allows us to be safe and secure without relying on a decision in minutes that could imperil the world.

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

Because whether you're delegating that decision to machines or to people, there are these failure modes.

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

And I don't know which is better, right?

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

I just reject the premise that we need to accept that.

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

It seems really implausible at this particular moment, given the height of tensions with