Menu
Sign In Search Podcasts Charts People & Topics Add Podcast API Pricing

Carl Robichaud

๐Ÿ‘ค Person
617 total appearances

Appearances Over Time

Podcast Appearances

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

And so they actually sent both weapons, Hiroshima and Nagasaki, out to the local commanders in the Pacific.

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

This is a time where communications took longer as well.

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

And there were preparations to use both of them when the weather conditions permitted.

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

And especially with the use of the bomb on Nagasaki, there was not a well-considered strategic decision to use that.

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

The bomb was used just three days after the initial bombing of Hiroshima.

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

Yeah, yeah.

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

But at the time the weapon was dropped, the Japanese were still making sense of what had happened with the first weapon.

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

And we're still processing that.

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

And as we know now, the Soviet Union was preparing to enter the war.

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

Truman knew this at the time, and he knew when the Soviet Union entered, it would be the end for Japan.

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

And he wrote that in his memoirs and his communications.

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

But there was a real interest in demonstrating the power of the bomb to the Soviet Union and in shaping the post-war balance.

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

The US had demanded unconditional surrender from Japan.

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

So the use of the bomb in some ways was to ensure an unconditional surrender without the invasion of the home islands.

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

And nobody knows exactly what would have happened if those weapons were not used.

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

But the consequences were just devastating.

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

So this was briefly considered.

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

And one of the considerations was that a demonstration in a harbor or off the coast may not show the full magnitude of the weapon and would not impress upon the Japanese and the Soviets the effect of this weapon.

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

There was also a concern, what if it didn't go off?

Making Sense with Sam Harris
#330 โ€” The Doomsday Machine

And then now you have a device that is in the water and could be retrievable by the enemy.