Carter Roy

If you're already part of the Crime House community, Murder True Crime Stories is a natural next listen.

New episodes drop every Tuesday and Thursday.

Beginning January 16th, new episodes will also drop every Friday.

Follow Murder True Crime Stories on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, or wherever you listen.

In 1926, Sister Amy came back from the dead.

At least, that's what it felt like to the members of the Four Square Church.

They thought she drowned in the Pacific Ocean six weeks ago.

There'd been an exhaustive search, even a memorial service.

But here Amy was, stepping off the train from Arizona.

A jubilant throng of over 30,000 people greeted her in downtown LA.

Firefighters hoisted her onto a chair and carried her through the crowd, while adoring citizens showered her with roses.

The parade in her honor wound through the city.

Over 100,000 people joined, including mounted officers, firefighters, and thousands of church members, sporting the same white dress and blue cape Amy wore when she preached.

When the parade reached Amy's temple, she found 5,000 people waiting on the street.

She shouted joyously that she loved them and praised the Lord.

Then she proceeded inside, where nearly 6,000 more faithful awaited her first sermon back.

In it, she detailed how she'd been kidnapped, but by the grace of God, escaped.

Some people called it a miracle.

But others called it a publicity stunt, and still more, a cover story for a woman who could no longer practice what she preached.

Welcome to Conspiracy Theories, a Spotify podcast.