Christopher Tapp

He'd just been through some rough stuff.

Yeah.

Did he apologize to you?

Multiple times, yeah.

You felt pretty bad about that.

He does.

Yes, fate.

Rarely what anyone expects.

Chris Tapp said he wanted to find the real killer now.

And so did this man, the new chief of the Idaho Falls Police, Bryce Johnson.

And so that's what the entire focus was, was finding that person.

Since the original investigation, Detective Ken Brown had retired.

Detective-turned-Mayor Jared Furman had developed Alzheimer's and withdrawn from public life.

So, to lead the reinvigorated investigation, the new chief promoted Bill Squires to Detective Captain.

It was Squires, remember, who worked the door at the original crime scene more than 20 years before.

My guidance for our staff was always, let's look at this completely differently again with the eyes that we have now and the technology we have now.

Squires didn't know it yet, but a woman known to be at the leading edge of that technology had been approached to work on the case.

And her first thought?

But of course, CeCe Moore had yet to encounter Carol Dodge.

Chris Tapp had a lot to get used to.