Collier Landry

I'm looking through the windshield watching him, and I just start rummaging through his truck, and I open up the center console. I find two photographs. One is of a house that I've never seen before. And the second one is of Sherry and her two kids sitting in front of fireplaces covered in plastic. And I'm like, okay, this is a new house. Clearly. I've never seen this before.

It's a brand new house.

It's a brand new house.

It's a brand new house.

After finding these photographs, Collier goes to school and calls Dave Messmore to tell him... about his discovery. From there, David Messmore would do some digging and what he would find would blow the case wide open. As it turns out, Jack Boyle's mistress, Sherry Campbell, wasn't just his girlfriend. Sherry and Jack had a baby together.

After finding these photographs, Collier goes to school and calls Dave Messmore to tell him... about his discovery. From there, David Messmore would do some digging and what he would find would blow the case wide open. As it turns out, Jack Boyle's mistress, Sherry Campbell, wasn't just his girlfriend. Sherry and Jack had a baby together.

After finding these photographs, Collier goes to school and calls Dave Messmore to tell him... about his discovery. From there, David Messmore would do some digging and what he would find would blow the case wide open. As it turns out, Jack Boyle's mistress, Sherry Campbell, wasn't just his girlfriend. Sherry and Jack had a baby together.

In fact, Sherry had just given birth to their full-term daughter less than two weeks after Noreen went missing. And that photograph that Collier found of Sherry and her kids sitting in a brand new house? Well, Jack had recently bought them that house. Soon enough, everything was starting to make sense. Jack Boyle had fallen in love with someone else. He started a family with someone else.

In fact, Sherry had just given birth to their full-term daughter less than two weeks after Noreen went missing. And that photograph that Collier found of Sherry and her kids sitting in a brand new house? Well, Jack had recently bought them that house. Soon enough, everything was starting to make sense. Jack Boyle had fallen in love with someone else. He started a family with someone else.

In fact, Sherry had just given birth to their full-term daughter less than two weeks after Noreen went missing. And that photograph that Collier found of Sherry and her kids sitting in a brand new house? Well, Jack had recently bought them that house. Soon enough, everything was starting to make sense. Jack Boyle had fallen in love with someone else. He started a family with someone else.

And he had clearly been planning to start a whole new life with her. But now the question was, did Noreen find out about this and run away? Or did Jack kill her to start this new life. As Dave Messmore is looking at all of this, he can't help but wonder if that new house holds the answers to Noreen Boyle's disappearance. So after a little digging, they find the house.

And he had clearly been planning to start a whole new life with her. But now the question was, did Noreen find out about this and run away? Or did Jack kill her to start this new life. As Dave Messmore is looking at all of this, he can't help but wonder if that new house holds the answers to Noreen Boyle's disappearance. So after a little digging, they find the house.

And he had clearly been planning to start a whole new life with her. But now the question was, did Noreen find out about this and run away? Or did Jack kill her to start this new life. As Dave Messmore is looking at all of this, he can't help but wonder if that new house holds the answers to Noreen Boyle's disappearance. So after a little digging, they find the house.

It was three hours away from Mansfield, Ohio in the town of Erie, Pennsylvania. Slowly but surely, investigators are uncovering more about Jack Boyle's double life. And based on what happens next, it's clear that Jack was becoming more and more paranoid. He knew that the walls were closing in.

It was three hours away from Mansfield, Ohio in the town of Erie, Pennsylvania. Slowly but surely, investigators are uncovering more about Jack Boyle's double life. And based on what happens next, it's clear that Jack was becoming more and more paranoid. He knew that the walls were closing in.

It was three hours away from Mansfield, Ohio in the town of Erie, Pennsylvania. Slowly but surely, investigators are uncovering more about Jack Boyle's double life. And based on what happens next, it's clear that Jack was becoming more and more paranoid. He knew that the walls were closing in.

What happened was, I was noticing over the weeks that my father was getting under more and more duress, and every single night, Every single night, Dave Messmore is coming to our house to try to talk to my dad. And his lawyer is there shutting him down. So this was like around the 20th or 21st of January, 1990.

What happened was, I was noticing over the weeks that my father was getting under more and more duress, and every single night, Every single night, Dave Messmore is coming to our house to try to talk to my dad. And his lawyer is there shutting him down. So this was like around the 20th or 21st of January, 1990.

What happened was, I was noticing over the weeks that my father was getting under more and more duress, and every single night, Every single night, Dave Messmore is coming to our house to try to talk to my dad. And his lawyer is there shutting him down. So this was like around the 20th or 21st of January, 1990.

My father comes to me, and again, he seems like he's under duress because he's probably like, why do they keep coming at me? And like, why are they finding out information? As to me, he goes, you know, Collier, I know that it's been really hard on you losing mommy and mommy leaving us. It was always mommy's left us in such a state. Mommy left us here. Mommy left us. That's what I'm always saying.