Dave Hanratty

It's also...

If you go into it not knowing what it's about, it is one of the most depressing films you'll ever see in terms of where it goes narratively.

It swept the Oscars, I think.

It definitely did well.

Oh, yeah.

I stand by hating the turn it takes after she gets injured.

I love it up until that moment, and then I found it just too...

yeah I don't know I didn't see that coming and then I was like oh Christ is that not a great kind of cinematic oh Christ and now Clint's gonna have to help her end her life I guess I don't know I just remember being when I was 12 when I saw it in the cinema so like I wasn't like oh Clint's gonna help her end her life this is so rich I was like ah this is like yeah but then you know it moved you viscerally Morgan Freeman's own you know his sole Oscar win was for Eddie Scrap Iron Dupree is that right is that right

You wouldn't think that, would you?

Hilary Swank got the Oscar.

Famously.

Yeah.

And like when she went, what, Makushla?

Is that what was on the back of her My Darling in Irish?

Ah, stop it.

Guys, I think you're being harsh on this.

No, I think it's good.

Look, it won five Oscars.

It doesn't need me to defend it.

But it was... I just didn't like narratively that right turn it made as a 12-year-old.