Deborah Roberts

And what did people say about this mom? I mean, she was, I guess, known to be a doting mother, right? They seem to have a solid marriage from what friends told us.

And what did people say about this mom? I mean, she was, I guess, known to be a doting mother, right? They seem to have a solid marriage from what friends told us.

And what did people say about this mom? I mean, she was, I guess, known to be a doting mother, right? They seem to have a solid marriage from what friends told us.

And her husband actually told us that, too. Well, let's play a clip from that 2016 show when Keith, her husband, describes reuniting with his wife Sherry at the hospital.

And her husband actually told us that, too. Well, let's play a clip from that 2016 show when Keith, her husband, describes reuniting with his wife Sherry at the hospital.

And her husband actually told us that, too. Well, let's play a clip from that 2016 show when Keith, her husband, describes reuniting with his wife Sherry at the hospital.

His voice is just dripping with emotion. Sean, at the time, you couldn't talk to law enforcement, but we had heard the story from her. And, you know, he talks about how could people do this to people. And she had told a story that she had been abducted and that these two women had held her and she was sort of somewhat still kind of bound when she was found.

His voice is just dripping with emotion. Sean, at the time, you couldn't talk to law enforcement, but we had heard the story from her. And, you know, he talks about how could people do this to people. And she had told a story that she had been abducted and that these two women had held her and she was sort of somewhat still kind of bound when she was found.

His voice is just dripping with emotion. Sean, at the time, you couldn't talk to law enforcement, but we had heard the story from her. And, you know, he talks about how could people do this to people. And she had told a story that she had been abducted and that these two women had held her and she was sort of somewhat still kind of bound when she was found.

Well, the two women abducting her, that sounded a little strange. I remember thinking that.

Well, the two women abducting her, that sounded a little strange. I remember thinking that.

Well, the two women abducting her, that sounded a little strange. I remember thinking that.

Like the book, like the famous book. Exactly.

Like the book, like the famous book. Exactly.

Like the book, like the famous book. Exactly.

So they wanted to give her the benefit of the doubt.

So they wanted to give her the benefit of the doubt.

So they wanted to give her the benefit of the doubt.

Yeah. And so a year goes by and then another year goes by. And clearly people were sort of wondering what happened here. And then all of a sudden, Sherry Papini goes from victim to suspect. What specifically did, you know, when did you start to find out that, I mean, didn't add up, of course, the whole notion of maybe she was, you know, there was a cult or something.

Yeah. And so a year goes by and then another year goes by. And clearly people were sort of wondering what happened here. And then all of a sudden, Sherry Papini goes from victim to suspect. What specifically did, you know, when did you start to find out that, I mean, didn't add up, of course, the whole notion of maybe she was, you know, there was a cult or something.