Deborah Roberts

He opens the door.

There's all this mud there, you know, this mold in it now, as you might imagine.

But it's still kind of intact.

I mean, it was almost like some kind of a tomb.

You know, there are magazines in there.

There are all the things that were there when she had the car.

So they begin looking.

And this is what gave me goosebumps.

He shows me the imprint of her shoe that would have scraped the side of the door.

And he shows me her actual boots that she was wearing that night that are caked in mud.

But that was critical because that showed them that she was placed inside that car.

And that was critical in this investigation, wasn't it?

Yeah, with more questions.

And police had questions at the time.

And then we fast forward to later, as you said.

2001 or so at that time.

But then later on, when the new investigators get involved, they, of course, now pick up where those questions left off.

And they start questioning people who had been closest to him.

Paul had this really good friend, and they questioned those folks.

But Paul, as we said, had an alibi.