Menu
Sign In Search Podcasts Charts People & Topics Add Podcast API Blog Pricing

Delaney Hall

๐Ÿ‘ค Speaker
371 total appearances

Appearances Over Time

Podcast Appearances

99% Invisible
Service Request #3: Why Is There So Much Litter in San Francisco?

And maybe the city could find a new design that worked better, was less vulnerable to trash picking, and maybe most importantly, was sturdier.

99% Invisible
Service Request #3: Why Is There So Much Litter in San Francisco?

Because here's another thing that happens in San Francisco.

99% Invisible
Service Request #3: Why Is There So Much Litter in San Francisco?

People attack the trash cans.

99% Invisible
Service Request #3: Why Is There So Much Litter in San Francisco?

The policy adventure continues when we come back.

99% Invisible
Service Request #3: Why Is There So Much Litter in San Francisco?

So after this experiment in the Mission District, you pivoted from adding cans to actually redesigning them.

99% Invisible
Service Request #3: Why Is There So Much Litter in San Francisco?

What led to that decision?

99% Invisible
Service Request #3: Why Is There So Much Litter in San Francisco?

The three custom trash can designs included the Salt and Pepper, which had a distinctive two-tiered shape with one section for bottles and cans and another for trash.

99% Invisible
Service Request #3: Why Is There So Much Litter in San Francisco?

Then there was the Slim Silhouette, a narrow can with stainless steel bars on the outside to discourage graffiti.

99% Invisible
Service Request #3: Why Is There So Much Litter in San Francisco?

And finally, there was the Soft Square, which featured curved panels and a foot pedal to open it.

99% Invisible
Service Request #3: Why Is There So Much Litter in San Francisco?

The city also picked three off-the-shelf garbage can models to include in the testing.

99% Invisible
Service Request #3: Why Is There So Much Litter in San Francisco?

And then they ran a two-and-a-half-month pilot, where they put out the six total models in 52 different locations across a broad range of neighborhoods.

99% Invisible
Service Request #3: Why Is There So Much Litter in San Francisco?

Then they invited the public to test them out and rate them.

99% Invisible
Service Request #3: Why Is There So Much Litter in San Francisco?

Eventually, thousands of people weighed in on the designs, and Rachel says they were mostly very thoughtful about it.

99% Invisible
Service Request #3: Why Is There So Much Litter in San Francisco?

But there was criticism, too.

99% Invisible
Service Request #3: Why Is There So Much Litter in San Francisco?

Some people were like, what are you doing, San Francisco Public Works?

99% Invisible
Service Request #3: Why Is There So Much Litter in San Francisco?

Why does the public have to weigh in on garbage cans?

99% Invisible
Service Request #3: Why Is There So Much Litter in San Francisco?

And then there was the cost of the prototypes.

99% Invisible
Service Request #3: Why Is There So Much Litter in San Francisco?

And sure enough, it did end up on Fox News.

99% Invisible
Service Request #3: Why Is There So Much Litter in San Francisco?

I'm curious because there was a lot of media focus on the cost rather than the design.

99% Invisible
Service Request #3: Why Is There So Much Litter in San Francisco?

How did you and your colleagues actually explain to the public why those prototypes were so expensive?