Dennis Murphy

And you'll be there, right, Andrea? Yes. But I was surprised by the gauntlet of people in front of the courthouse. Turtle Boy. Friends of Karen. Yeah.

Was this murder for hire? Did someone know that he had plans for something?

Was this murder for hire? Did someone know that he had plans for something?

Here I was before this house that was all over the headlines called the House of Horrors. And it turned out to be all of that.

Here I was before this house that was all over the headlines called the House of Horrors. And it turned out to be all of that.

Hey, Andrea. How are you?

Hey, Andrea. How are you?

Oh, I so well remember standing there looking at that little building, Andrea. Here's Perugia, this medieval beauty of a town known for making chocolate and educating students. And yet here I was before this house that was all over the headlines called the House of Horrors. And it turned out to be all of that.

Oh, I so well remember standing there looking at that little building, Andrea. Here's Perugia, this medieval beauty of a town known for making chocolate and educating students. And yet here I was before this house that was all over the headlines called the House of Horrors. And it turned out to be all of that.

Well, our most interesting stop on that trip, we went to the office of the chief prosecutor. And he sat us down and he took us through this very lurid operatic theory of the crime. He said there were three people involved here. It was three on one. It was a sex game gone wrong.

Well, our most interesting stop on that trip, we went to the office of the chief prosecutor. And he sat us down and he took us through this very lurid operatic theory of the crime. He said there were three people involved here. It was three on one. It was a sex game gone wrong.

Amanda Knox holding the victim with a knife under her chin, her boyfriend of just a few days, an Italian boyfriend, and a third man who sexually assaulted the roommate. And it all took place in that little cottage, the House of Horrors.

Amanda Knox holding the victim with a knife under her chin, her boyfriend of just a few days, an Italian boyfriend, and a third man who sexually assaulted the roommate. And it all took place in that little cottage, the House of Horrors.

The Italian authorities leaked every bit of information I think they had at the time, especially to the British tabloids. The media had a field day when it found Amanda's MySpace webpage. Her online nickname was Foxy Noxy. Who was Foxy Noxy, this young woman seen in her high school photo playing soccer? And it was nothing more than that. That was an allusion to her ability to play soccer.

The Italian authorities leaked every bit of information I think they had at the time, especially to the British tabloids. The media had a field day when it found Amanda's MySpace webpage. Her online nickname was Foxy Noxy. Who was Foxy Noxy, this young woman seen in her high school photo playing soccer? And it was nothing more than that. That was an allusion to her ability to play soccer.

But somehow this appellation that she was known as Foxy Noxy became this portrayal of a promiscuous young American woman.

But somehow this appellation that she was known as Foxy Noxy became this portrayal of a promiscuous young American woman.

Exactly. The court of public opinion had decided, we've seen her in the paper every day. What is she doing? Giggling while she's buying lingerie with her boyfriend. What is the story we hear about being in the police station doing cartwheels? It all added up to a guilty on that side of the Atlantic.

Exactly. The court of public opinion had decided, we've seen her in the paper every day. What is she doing? Giggling while she's buying lingerie with her boyfriend. What is the story we hear about being in the police station doing cartwheels? It all added up to a guilty on that side of the Atlantic.

She didn't. They bring her in, and she doesn't have an attorney, and she's being interrogated by the homicide detectives in Italian. And she gives up what they said at the time was something like a confession, where she seemed to implicate herself by being in the house. She recalled the screams of Meredith. And the other thing that happened is that they said, who is the third man?