Menu
Sign In Search Podcasts Libraries Charts People & Topics Add Podcast API Blog Pricing

Dr Emma Farrell

๐Ÿ‘ค Speaker
67 total appearances

Appearances Over Time

Podcast Appearances

Today with David McCullagh
Birth order: what does it mean and does it really shape who we are?

So it's not perfect, but it's a really well empirically supported measure of personality.

Today with David McCullagh
Birth order: what does it mean and does it really shape who we are?

But one of the traits that's measured in this is conscientiousness.

Today with David McCullagh
Birth order: what does it mean and does it really shape who we are?

And we know that as people get older, their conscientiousness tends to increase slightly.

Today with David McCullagh
Birth order: what does it mean and does it really shape who we are?

So that gives the eldest child an unfair advantage.

Today with David McCullagh
Birth order: what does it mean and does it really shape who we are?

They're always going to be more conscientious, by virtue of being older.

Today with David McCullagh
Birth order: what does it mean and does it really shape who we are?

But the researchers were able to control for that.

Today with David McCullagh
Birth order: what does it mean and does it really shape who we are?

And when they did, they didn't find any difference in conscientiousness amongst elder children and their younger siblings.

Today with David McCullagh
Birth order: what does it mean and does it really shape who we are?

Yes, so there is some data to suggest that eldest children score just a teeny tiny amount of IQ points higher on IQ tests.

Today with David McCullagh
Birth order: what does it mean and does it really shape who we are?

But before the eldest children start lighting up family WhatsApp groups all around the country, this is a tiny, tiny difference.

Today with David McCullagh
Birth order: what does it mean and does it really shape who we are?

And it's thought to be down to all of that extra cognitive stimulation and attention that eldest children get.

Today with David McCullagh
Birth order: what does it mean and does it really shape who we are?

And they are also more likely to teach their younger siblings.

Today with David McCullagh
Birth order: what does it mean and does it really shape who we are?

So they've gotten really good at the tasks that we use, that IQ tests use as a proxy measure for intelligence.

Today with David McCullagh
Birth order: what does it mean and does it really shape who we are?

But we know IQ tests are kind of a contested measure of intelligence and also shaped by things like parental expectations and education in ways that are far more influential than birth order.

Today with David McCullagh
Birth order: what does it mean and does it really shape who we are?

So personality is a term we use to describe the relatively stable set of thoughts, feelings and behaviours that shape how we interact with the world.

Today with David McCullagh
Birth order: what does it mean and does it really shape who we are?

So what makes you, you and me, me is a question that has really engaged the greatest minds for thousands of years.

Today with David McCullagh
Birth order: what does it mean and does it really shape who we are?

If you go back to Socrates and Aristotle, they were really thinking about the role of nature and nurture and shaping who we are.

Today with David McCullagh
Birth order: what does it mean and does it really shape who we are?

And psychology would say that personality is a combination of nature and nurture.

Today with David McCullagh
Birth order: what does it mean and does it really shape who we are?

So it's somewhat inherited and it's somewhat shaped by our environment, our experiences, the resources and people we had around us as we navigate various life demands and challenges.

Today with David McCullagh
Birth order: what does it mean and does it really shape who we are?

It's one of those big contested debates in psychology, the degree to which it's nature or nurture.

Today with David McCullagh
Birth order: what does it mean and does it really shape who we are?

But I think we're pretty clear that birth order doesn't have very much to do with it.