Edward Gibson
๐ค SpeakerAppearances Over Time
Podcast Appearances
I mean, that's the mechanism. If it's modeling, I think it's kind of really interesting that it can't. That it's really interesting. I think it's potentially underlyingly modeling something like the way the form is processed.
So what I like about dependency grammar is it makes... The cognitive cost associated with longer distance connections, very transparent. It turns out there is a cost associated with producing and comprehending connections between words which are just not beside each other. The further apart they are, the worse it is, according to, well, we can measure that.
So what I like about dependency grammar is it makes... The cognitive cost associated with longer distance connections, very transparent. It turns out there is a cost associated with producing and comprehending connections between words which are just not beside each other. The further apart they are, the worse it is, according to, well, we can measure that.
So what I like about dependency grammar is it makes... The cognitive cost associated with longer distance connections, very transparent. It turns out there is a cost associated with producing and comprehending connections between words which are just not beside each other. The further apart they are, the worse it is, according to, well, we can measure that.
And there is a cost associated with that.
And there is a cost associated with that.
And there is a cost associated with that.
Sure. And how do you measure it? Oh, well, you can measure it in a lot of ways. The simplest is just asking people to say how good a sentence sounds. That's one way to measure. And you try to triangulate then across sentences and across structures to try to figure out what the source of that is. You can look at...
Sure. And how do you measure it? Oh, well, you can measure it in a lot of ways. The simplest is just asking people to say how good a sentence sounds. That's one way to measure. And you try to triangulate then across sentences and across structures to try to figure out what the source of that is. You can look at...
Sure. And how do you measure it? Oh, well, you can measure it in a lot of ways. The simplest is just asking people to say how good a sentence sounds. That's one way to measure. And you try to triangulate then across sentences and across structures to try to figure out what the source of that is. You can look at...
reading times in controlled materials, in certain kinds of materials, and then we can measure the dependency distances there. There's a recent study which looked at, we're talking about the brain here, we could look at the language network, okay? We could look at the language network and we could look at the activation in the language network
reading times in controlled materials, in certain kinds of materials, and then we can measure the dependency distances there. There's a recent study which looked at, we're talking about the brain here, we could look at the language network, okay? We could look at the language network and we could look at the activation in the language network
reading times in controlled materials, in certain kinds of materials, and then we can measure the dependency distances there. There's a recent study which looked at, we're talking about the brain here, we could look at the language network, okay? We could look at the language network and we could look at the activation in the language network
And how big the activation is depending on the length of the dependencies. And it turns out in just random sentences that you're listening to, if you're listening to, so it turns out there are people listening to stories here. And the bigger, the longer the dependency is, the stronger the activation in the language network.
And how big the activation is depending on the length of the dependencies. And it turns out in just random sentences that you're listening to, if you're listening to, so it turns out there are people listening to stories here. And the bigger, the longer the dependency is, the stronger the activation in the language network.
And how big the activation is depending on the length of the dependencies. And it turns out in just random sentences that you're listening to, if you're listening to, so it turns out there are people listening to stories here. And the bigger, the longer the dependency is, the stronger the activation in the language network.
And so there's some measure, there's a bunch of different measures we could do. That's kind of a neat measure, actually, of actual activations. Activation in the brain.
And so there's some measure, there's a bunch of different measures we could do. That's kind of a neat measure, actually, of actual activations. Activation in the brain.
And so there's some measure, there's a bunch of different measures we could do. That's kind of a neat measure, actually, of actual activations. Activation in the brain.
Yeah, it's complicated, but probably it's doable. I would guess it's doable. I tried to do that a while ago, and I was reasonably successful, but for some reason I stopped working on it. on that. I agree with you that it would be nice to figure out. So there's like some way to figure out the cost. I mean, it's complicated. Another issue you raised before was like, how do you measure distance?