Menu
Sign In Search Podcasts Charts People & Topics Add Podcast API Blog Pricing

Eneasz Brodsky

๐Ÿ‘ค Speaker
617 total appearances

Appearances Over Time

Podcast Appearances

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

This is why it was so hard to... Why it took 11 years for people to figure out what the story is about.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

It never tells you this.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

It only shows you it.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

And...

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

like seeing it across a work this long took some major skills.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

So huge props to William on this.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

But, and so this, this even happened in, I'm going to refer back to Alexander Wales's essay as a foil for this.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

Alexander Wales says that the core conflict between Voldemort and Harry doesn't even, the plot, the conflict plot doesn't even begin until chapter 83 or something, because until then it's 88.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

Okay.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

Sorry.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

I love it.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

You're a good rationalist being the correct amount of pedantic there.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

Before that, it's just Quirrell and Harry and they're not fighting.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

There isn't really a conflict between them.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

And in 88 is like where the two of them come to a head where they're fighting against each other.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

and that the other major plot conflict is between Coral and Dumbledore, and that's entirely off-screen, with Harry sometimes seeing the consequences of it.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

And so it sucks that it's two-thirds of the way through the book before the central plot even starts, and then it's resolved through violence at the end, and...

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

And William says, no, no, no, you're misreading what the plot actually is.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

There's a single clear main plot, which is foreshadowed in chapter one and established in chapter six, and then properly begins in chapter 16, and then goes on for 100 chapters until it's finally resolved in chapter 114.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

And that plot is that he says this is a standard Disney plot where somebody wants something.