Menu
Sign In Search Podcasts Charts People & Topics Add Podcast API Blog Pricing

Eneasz Brodsky

๐Ÿ‘ค Speaker
617 total appearances

Appearances Over Time

Podcast Appearances

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

He doesn't need to corrupt him because, of course, Harry's evil.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

Like, he's a copy of Quirrell.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

He's totally got to be evil, right?

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

It says, only in chapter 20 does Quirrell realize he has a problem.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

And then the rest of the plot is Quirrell seducing Harry to evil.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

And on the other side of that is Hermione.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

And Hermione represents trust in reason and logic to solve the world's problems, the morality of the modern world, and Harry's ties to his friends and family.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

And...

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

everything else in the story.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

As he's overcoming his initial mistake of trusting Quirrell is something that's either pushing him closer to Quirrell and his nice sounding answers about how you can use evil to solve the world's problems or pushing him away from Quirrell and back towards Hermione and righteousness.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

And that is how the plot resolves through this back and forth conflict between the two of them.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

And every time one of them scores a major goal, they also score some kind of... Either the other side also scores a goal or they score some kind of setback so that there continues to be a tension between the two of them.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

And it keeps ratcheting up, but it doesn't stay static.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

Things happen and battles are won and lost.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

But they are won and lost with consequences that keep them fighting instead of resolving one way or the other.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

And in fact, less so.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

I think Eliezer has this quote that if you're writing Lord of the Rings fanfic and you give Frodo a lightsaber, then you have to give Sauron a Death Star.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

And I think this is the same thing where the, the reason like Hermione has been leveled up so much to the point that Eliezer calls her Mary Sue is because on the other side of her is fricking Quirrell.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

Quirrell is amazing.

The Bayesian Conspiracy
254 โ€“ The True Theme and Meaning of HPMOR

He's everything Harry ever wanted aside from the evil part.