Gerard Waitley

Bucks was brilliant.

But for sheer magic, Dacos is the one.

Nick will end up probably the best, even if he is not as brilliant as his dad.

I'm of generation recency bias, Dacos, Buckley, Picken, McKenna, Pendlebury, Thompson, Price, with a special mention to Carmen and Greening.

Greatest pile in Thompson.

Discussion of who is the greatest, but it's perfect demonstration of recency bias.

Gordon Coventry is in no one's mind under the age of 50, but his record is amazing.

Even in my time, I'd put Dacos above Pendlebury.

Peter Dacos, that's from Guy.

While Pendlebury has had a far longer career with the extra flag, Dane Swan was a level above for five years during both of their prime.

That's from Marcus.

Gordon Coventry is the best pie.

Ted Whitten is the best dog.

But like with all recency bias, Pendlebury and Bonson-Pelly will be touted as the club's goat.

If you haven't done so, I recommend the book Rose Boys written by Peter Rose.

Bob Rose would have won a couple of flags as coach with half an ounce of luck.

John from Mernda.

Sid Coventry, four-time Premiership captain, only to do so.

Brownlow and best on field in the 27 grand final.

And there's no doubt it's Bucks.