Host / Investigative Reporter

David Trump has told police that Mia Stone claims she got the scar when her ex-husband tried to run her over.

And now she wanted to move to Texas and marry Trumpus.

About a week later, Jolene Cummings goes missing.

Not long after, Trempus says he got a call from the sheriff's office in Florida asking if he knew a woman named Mia Stone.

Her true name is Kimberly Kessler.

So investigators are left to wonder, had Jolene figured out Kessler's grand deception?

No one had any idea how truly evil she was.

And had Kessler retaliated by doing the unthinkable?

When Jennifer Seibert first arrived in Fernandina Beach in 2018, no one had a clue about her trail of chaos and red flags over the years.

Let me tell you what, Jillian was very inquisitive, very intuitive.

And when she said someone's fake, it's like you're putting on an act or you're not who you say you are.

So was Jolene on the verge of discovering the real story about the woman now known as Kimberly Kessler?

I believe 100% that Jolene was going to check to see who she was.

Investigators uncovered text messages Jolene had sent about the new employee, suggesting there was something off about her that she couldn't quite put her finger on.

Did you get a vibe between the two of them when she was in the salon?

Yeah.

Kimberly was kind of standoffish, and there was definitely some tension between them.

Well, the theory is that Jolene Cummings was dangerously close to discovering, number one, that Jennifer Seibert was not Jennifer Seibert, and number two, who she might really be.

Towards the end, it had gotten contentious to the point that they would yell at one another in front of clients.

And there had been a fight in particular where the argument ended and Jolene looked at her client and said, there's something going on with her.