Ian Carroll
π€ SpeakerAppearances Over Time
Podcast Appearances
But you don't like as a Jewish person, you're now faced with this choice. Do I stand by Israel always forever for everything and defend everything they do? Or do I get labeled as a self-hating Jew like Dave Smith gets labeled, like Glenn Greenwald gets labeled? Do I stand against all of my culture and do I get ostracized by my family and by my community? Right. Right. Right. Right. Right.
But you don't like as a Jewish person, you're now faced with this choice. Do I stand by Israel always forever for everything and defend everything they do? Or do I get labeled as a self-hating Jew like Dave Smith gets labeled, like Glenn Greenwald gets labeled? Do I stand against all of my culture and do I get ostracized by my family and by my community? Right. Right. Right. Right. Right.
Yeah. And so it just puts us all in this impossible situation, and it's an impossible conversation that we... And I'm glad for it because it's a maturing process. And I think we need to do it very delicately and very carefully and thoughtfully because Jewish people are people and they're not evil. But there are evil Jewish people and there are evil American people and there are evil Saudi people.
Yeah. And so it just puts us all in this impossible situation, and it's an impossible conversation that we... And I'm glad for it because it's a maturing process. And I think we need to do it very delicately and very carefully and thoughtfully because Jewish people are people and they're not evil. But there are evil Jewish people and there are evil American people and there are evil Saudi people.
Yeah. And so it just puts us all in this impossible situation, and it's an impossible conversation that we... And I'm glad for it because it's a maturing process. And I think we need to do it very delicately and very carefully and thoughtfully because Jewish people are people and they're not evil. But there are evil Jewish people and there are evil American people and there are evil Saudi people.
And that's the way it is. Well said. Right? Well said. And so I welcome the conversation. But unfortunately, the thing...
And that's the way it is. Well said. Right? Well said. And so I welcome the conversation. But unfortunately, the thing...
And that's the way it is. Well said. Right? Well said. And so I welcome the conversation. But unfortunately, the thing...
for me, fortunately, is when I first researched it, I came across this documentary on Rumble called The Occupation of the American Mind, which is a very well put together documentary that is mostly Jewish people speaking about the history of Israel and about how they realized in the 80s when there was this specific operation where they wound up bombing this refugee camp called Sabra and Shatila, or a refugee camp in a place called Sabra and Shatila.
for me, fortunately, is when I first researched it, I came across this documentary on Rumble called The Occupation of the American Mind, which is a very well put together documentary that is mostly Jewish people speaking about the history of Israel and about how they realized in the 80s when there was this specific operation where they wound up bombing this refugee camp called Sabra and Shatila, or a refugee camp in a place called Sabra and Shatila.
for me, fortunately, is when I first researched it, I came across this documentary on Rumble called The Occupation of the American Mind, which is a very well put together documentary that is mostly Jewish people speaking about the history of Israel and about how they realized in the 80s when there was this specific operation where they wound up bombing this refugee camp called Sabra and Shatila, or a refugee camp in a place called Sabra and Shatila.
And there was other bombing, like atrocities. It was like, I guess it was a massacre, it wasn't a bombing. And it was the first time where Western journalists had taken video cameras over there and video feed were coming back of the conflict of what was happening. And American sentiment turned really harshly against Israel in the 80s there.
And there was other bombing, like atrocities. It was like, I guess it was a massacre, it wasn't a bombing. And it was the first time where Western journalists had taken video cameras over there and video feed were coming back of the conflict of what was happening. And American sentiment turned really harshly against Israel in the 80s there.
And there was other bombing, like atrocities. It was like, I guess it was a massacre, it wasn't a bombing. And it was the first time where Western journalists had taken video cameras over there and video feed were coming back of the conflict of what was happening. And American sentiment turned really harshly against Israel in the 80s there.
And they realized we don't need to win just the kinetic war. We need to win the ideological war on the global scale. Because if we don't win that ideological war, the whole world will turn against us and call us a colonial project, which I would argue they kind of are. But that's not the point here. And I don't mean to say I'm necessarily right about my perspective on that.
And they realized we don't need to win just the kinetic war. We need to win the ideological war on the global scale. Because if we don't win that ideological war, the whole world will turn against us and call us a colonial project, which I would argue they kind of are. But that's not the point here. And I don't mean to say I'm necessarily right about my perspective on that.
And they realized we don't need to win just the kinetic war. We need to win the ideological war on the global scale. Because if we don't win that ideological war, the whole world will turn against us and call us a colonial project, which I would argue they kind of are. But that's not the point here. And I don't mean to say I'm necessarily right about my perspective on that.
But that's when they switched to a propaganda war and they started targeting the United States with propaganda. And they hired the world's top propagandists to tell to teach Israelis and Israeli military officials and government officials how to communicate with the West and how to propagandize the West so that we would remain neutral. In the dark a little bit.
But that's when they switched to a propaganda war and they started targeting the United States with propaganda. And they hired the world's top propagandists to tell to teach Israelis and Israeli military officials and government officials how to communicate with the West and how to propagandize the West so that we would remain neutral. In the dark a little bit.
But that's when they switched to a propaganda war and they started targeting the United States with propaganda. And they hired the world's top propagandists to tell to teach Israelis and Israeli military officials and government officials how to communicate with the West and how to propagandize the West so that we would remain neutral. In the dark a little bit.