Imam Mohammad Tawhidi

An infallible human being that does not make mistakes at all or any error.

So it's impossible that he would make such a decision.

And plus the issue of Aisha, you have to weigh it against the society and the dates around her.

She was born after her sister Asma and she died before Asma.

And I have it in a study which I can definitely send you.

She was either 18, from 18 to 21 years old.

There is no Muslim consensus that Aisha was 3 or 6 or 9 or 15.

There are more popular opinions because there is a state behind the publications promoting them.

Yes, that I accept.

But again, with all due respect, if you put a book in front of me, a history book, and you tell me this book was authored by a very respected man, you know what I'll tell you?

I'll tell you with all due respect, Brother Patrick, I know you gave me a book.

You put a book in front of me, but God gave me a brain, and I can do mathematics, and I can understand exactly when she was born, where she was.

It's not hard to work it out.

Well, 18 to 21.

Okay.

Final verdict.

But they are.

So the two sources are debating each other.

Again, a source is measured and is judged based on the author and based on the credibility of the source.

So when you're telling me that she was, it's narrated that she's six or nine, I understand where that comes from.