James Addy

Along Route M, there were a couple of items of evidence that were located, including an ammunition box.

It was an empty .22 caliber ammunition box.

At that point, I wanted to make a notification to him that there had been an incident involving Molly.

The Highway Patrol trooper does one of the more unfortunate parts of a law enforcement officer's job, to go notify somebody that their loved one is dead.

So they went to his house that evening.

They're expecting that he's going to be devastated that they found the body of his fiancee.

What they didn't realize is that the shocking news that was going to be delivered to them would change this investigation immediately.

This is an unbelievable story.

This is a story about a double life.

Those lives were set on a collision course when he and Molly Watson began planning a wedding.

He had told Molly that his wife died in a terrible accident.

Two days before this long-awaited marriage, Polly's found murder.

It's just built and built and built, and somebody is living with a lot of secrets.

His name is James Addy.

The Highway Patrol trooper does a sort of unfortunate part of a law enforcement officer's job to go notify somebody that their loved one is dead.

So Sheriff Colston, along with a couple of members of the Missouri State Highway Patrol, went from the crime scene to James Addy's home.

Molly Watson was basically murdered at the midway point between James Addy's home and her home.

So they go to his house outside of Mexico, Missouri, which is, let's say, 25 miles away.

Very late, the point that we're getting to his house, right around 2 in the morning.

Went to knock on the door.