James Addy

And he took me to go meet her, and she made a costume for me.

What was James Addy thinking, introducing this secret girlfriend to his own daughter?

And of course, the daughter has no clue what she means to him.

I mean, why?

Why would he do this?

Did you know about his relationship with Molly?

No.

She articulated to the jury what she saw and heard and remembered from that night.

I was still up doing homework at around 10 p.m.

And that's when, that's around the time that dad came home.

Specifically that he got home at 10 o'clock, not 8.30.

On cross-examination, the defense really tries to create some doubt with timing as to when James Addy actually got home.

Even though Emma says it was 10 o'clock, maybe he had gotten home earlier.

Maybe he was in the garage working on his car.

Maybe she didn't know.

You'd agree with me that back in this time frame that your dad would frequently be in the garage, correct?

The T-shirt becomes so important to this case because it's a one-of-a-kind T-shirt.

And here's the kicker.

It was made by James Addy's daughter, Emma.

Yes.