Janice Morgan

It's not far from the Wicklow Mountains, so if she still plans to go for a walk, it makes sense to go this way. There's a gap in the timeline for the next five and a half hours until 9 p.m. That's when witnesses spot someone matching Annie's description at a pub about three miles outside of Enniscarry. It's a touristy spot called Johnny Fox's.

It's not far from the Wicklow Mountains, so if she still plans to go for a walk, it makes sense to go this way. There's a gap in the timeline for the next five and a half hours until 9 p.m. That's when witnesses spot someone matching Annie's description at a pub about three miles outside of Enniscarry. It's a touristy spot called Johnny Fox's.

Numerous witnesses say they saw this woman with an unidentified man. He's clean-shaven and well-dressed. The bouncer at Johnny Fox's describes him as a, quote, yuppie. Annie has never said anything to her friends and family about having a boyfriend, but whoever this woman is who looks just like Annie seems to be on a date.

Numerous witnesses say they saw this woman with an unidentified man. He's clean-shaven and well-dressed. The bouncer at Johnny Fox's describes him as a, quote, yuppie. Annie has never said anything to her friends and family about having a boyfriend, but whoever this woman is who looks just like Annie seems to be on a date.

The yuppie guy meets her outside the pub, pays her cover, and buys her drinks for the rest of the night. The next day, Annie's friends show up at her apartment for the big birthday dinner. But when they knock, no one answers. Annie's not home. Around the same time, her roommates get back from a weekend away. They go inside and find the apartment in disarray.

The yuppie guy meets her outside the pub, pays her cover, and buys her drinks for the rest of the night. The next day, Annie's friends show up at her apartment for the big birthday dinner. But when they knock, no one answers. Annie's not home. Around the same time, her roommates get back from a weekend away. They go inside and find the apartment in disarray.

The spoiled groceries are still sitting out, and so is the ironing board and the phone book. It looks like Annie was halfway through her chores when she dropped everything and left. Unnerved, Annie's friends call her father John in the United States to let him know what's going on. John's alarm bells go off immediately. He knows his daughter.

The spoiled groceries are still sitting out, and so is the ironing board and the phone book. It looks like Annie was halfway through her chores when she dropped everything and left. Unnerved, Annie's friends call her father John in the United States to let him know what's going on. John's alarm bells go off immediately. He knows his daughter.

Even from across the Atlantic Ocean, she's always easy to reach. She wouldn't just take off or suddenly stop communicating with the people she loves. Plus, John's a former police officer, so he knows how crucial it is to move quickly after someone goes missing. Right away, he and Annie's mother, Nancy, get on a plane to Ireland.

Even from across the Atlantic Ocean, she's always easy to reach. She wouldn't just take off or suddenly stop communicating with the people she loves. Plus, John's a former police officer, so he knows how crucial it is to move quickly after someone goes missing. Right away, he and Annie's mother, Nancy, get on a plane to Ireland.

By March 30th, four days after Annie was last seen, she's officially reported missing. The Irish police, called the Guardie, are on the case. And on the advice of the American Embassy, the McCarricks hire a private detective. The investigators chase a couple leads that go nowhere. Witnesses claim they've seen Annie in other parts of Ireland, but the guardie can't confirm the sightings.

By March 30th, four days after Annie was last seen, she's officially reported missing. The Irish police, called the Guardie, are on the case. And on the advice of the American Embassy, the McCarricks hire a private detective. The investigators chase a couple leads that go nowhere. Witnesses claim they've seen Annie in other parts of Ireland, but the guardie can't confirm the sightings.

They also aren't able to determine the identity of the man at Johnny Fox's pub. Weeks go by with no breaks. John and Nancy's biggest goal is to hold the investigators' feet to the fire. It's horrible for their daughter to go missing, and it would be even worse for the case to go cold. They keep the pressure on by making sure Annie's story stays in the news.

They also aren't able to determine the identity of the man at Johnny Fox's pub. Weeks go by with no breaks. John and Nancy's biggest goal is to hold the investigators' feet to the fire. It's horrible for their daughter to go missing, and it would be even worse for the case to go cold. They keep the pressure on by making sure Annie's story stays in the news.

One evening, sometime around early May, a report about Annie's disappearance airs on TV. She's been missing for a little over a month. A local woman named Colette McCann catches the broadcast and thinks to herself, what an unimaginable thing to go through. She has no idea that just a few months later, she'll know exactly how the McCarricks feel.

One evening, sometime around early May, a report about Annie's disappearance airs on TV. She's been missing for a little over a month. A local woman named Colette McCann catches the broadcast and thinks to herself, what an unimaginable thing to go through. She has no idea that just a few months later, she'll know exactly how the McCarricks feel.

On July 25th, 1993, Colette attends a family gathering in the Dublin area. Her sister, Eva Brennan, is also there. Eva is a devout Catholic who's really involved with her church. She's 5'7 with short brown hair. She's 39 years old, but her family says she looks younger. It's not a perfect match, but she kind of looks like Annie McCarrick.

On July 25th, 1993, Colette attends a family gathering in the Dublin area. Her sister, Eva Brennan, is also there. Eva is a devout Catholic who's really involved with her church. She's 5'7 with short brown hair. She's 39 years old, but her family says she looks younger. It's not a perfect match, but she kind of looks like Annie McCarrick.

For dinner, Eva and Colette's mother serves lamb, but Eva's not a fan. And that causes some problems. After Eva complains about the food, it sparks an argument that leads to Eva storming out of the house. Eva's family worries about her, especially after she doesn't reach out again for the rest of the night or the next morning.

For dinner, Eva and Colette's mother serves lamb, but Eva's not a fan. And that causes some problems. After Eva complains about the food, it sparks an argument that leads to Eva storming out of the house. Eva's family worries about her, especially after she doesn't reach out again for the rest of the night or the next morning.