Jennifer Gould

At his first court appearance last month, Nick was forced to wear a blue suicide smock, but he's since been taken off suicide watch.

As the 32-year-old stares down a potential needle, Reiner remains held without bail with his next date with destiny set for February 23rd.

A 911 call has surfaced from the home of a beloved Ohio dentist and his wife, revealing a sobbing woman reporting a heated domestic dispute just two months before the pair was executed in their upstairs bedroom.

Spencer Tepe, 37, and his wife, Monique, 39, were found riddled with bullets while their two toddlers and family dog remained unharmed downstairs.

This early morning distress call from April 15th, 2025, captured a woman wailing to dispatchers that she, end quote, my man got into it, end quote, at 2.45 in the morning.

Listen.

Yeah, I'm sorry.

I'm okay.

I promise.

While the caller insisted the fight was not physical, Monique's brother-in-law, Rob Misle, says the voice is, quote, obviously not Monique and, quote, suggesting a guest or third party was involved in the late night drama.

The mystery deepens as a neighbor just down the street reported a terrified 911 call on December 19th, just 11 days before the murders, claiming a stranger was smashing and banging on her door at 2.30 a.m.

The woman told dispatchers someone was trying to get in, but the intruder vanished before police arrived at the home, located just a three-minute walk from the Tepe's.

The nightmare officially unfolded on the morning of December 30th, when Spencer's boss at Athens Dental Depot called 911 from Florida, frantic because the devoted dentist, who was always on time, had failed to show up for work.

Coworkers and a friend rushed to the Wineland Park residence after an uneventful police response and were met with the sound of children crying inside.

Looking through a window, they made a bone-chilling discovery.

Spencer's body was crumpled on the floor and a pool of blood next to the bed.

Officials say Spencer had reportedly been blasted multiple times and Monique was hit in the chest with a bullet sometime between 2 a.m.

and 5 a.m.

The calculated violence stands in jarring contrast.

to the couple's private life.