Menu
Sign In Search Podcasts Charts People & Topics Add Podcast API Blog Pricing

Jim Campbell

๐Ÿ‘ค Speaker
102 total appearances

Appearances Over Time

Podcast Appearances

Morning Wire
The Major Ruling SCOTUS Handed Down and What Comes Next

But the rest of the court saw right through that and recognized that when you're sitting down having a conversation across the table from someone, that that's obviously speech and it must be protected by the First Amendment.

Morning Wire
The Major Ruling SCOTUS Handed Down and What Comes Next

There are over 20 states that have laws just like Colorado's, and there are over 100 localities that have similar laws as well.

Morning Wire
The Major Ruling SCOTUS Handed Down and What Comes Next

The Supreme Court's decision makes very clear that those laws face a

Morning Wire
The Major Ruling SCOTUS Handed Down and What Comes Next

very significant burden if they're ever going to be applied to simple conversations between counselors and clients.

Morning Wire
The Major Ruling SCOTUS Handed Down and What Comes Next

And so we're very optimistic that this is the end of those laws to the extent governments try to apply them to shut down voluntary conversations between counselors and their clients.

Morning Wire
The Major Ruling SCOTUS Handed Down and What Comes Next

Well, I would start with the language of the 14th Amendment because the 14th Amendment speaks directly to the issue of citizenship.

Morning Wire
The Major Ruling SCOTUS Handed Down and What Comes Next

And it says that all persons born or naturalized in the United States and subject to the jurisdiction thereof are citizens of the United States.

Morning Wire
The Major Ruling SCOTUS Handed Down and What Comes Next

Now, that was originally approved by the people in order to grant citizenship to freed slaves.

Morning Wire
The Major Ruling SCOTUS Handed Down and What Comes Next

But over time, some have come to understand that as allowing people

Morning Wire
The Major Ruling SCOTUS Handed Down and What Comes Next

birthright citizenship to children born to illegal immigrants.

Morning Wire
The Major Ruling SCOTUS Handed Down and What Comes Next

But President Trump, on his first day back in office, he signed an order saying that babies born in the US will no longer automatically get citizenship

Morning Wire
The Major Ruling SCOTUS Handed Down and What Comes Next

if their parents are here illegally or only temporarily.

Morning Wire
The Major Ruling SCOTUS Handed Down and What Comes Next

And then very, very soon after that, the ACLU filed a lawsuit, and so that order has never been able to go into effect.

Morning Wire
The Major Ruling SCOTUS Handed Down and What Comes Next

Yeah, the case really hinges on a phrase that I recited before.

Morning Wire
The Major Ruling SCOTUS Handed Down and What Comes Next

So in that 14th Amendment language, it says, subject to the jurisdiction of the United States.

Morning Wire
The Major Ruling SCOTUS Handed Down and What Comes Next

And so both sides dispute what that means.

Morning Wire
The Major Ruling SCOTUS Handed Down and What Comes Next

On the one hand, the challengers to those laws say that being subject to the jurisdiction just means that you're subject to the laws.

Morning Wire
The Major Ruling SCOTUS Handed Down and What Comes Next

And so anyone that's present in the US is subject to US laws.

Morning Wire
The Major Ruling SCOTUS Handed Down and What Comes Next

And if that's the proper understanding...

Morning Wire
The Major Ruling SCOTUS Handed Down and What Comes Next

then birthright citizenship should belong to anyone born in the US.