Jim Mosley
speaker
103 appearances
1 recordings
1 series
first heard Apr 2025
last heard Apr 2025
Jim Mosley’s voice in public audio — every appearance, attributed to the second.
Trend
recordings per month · last 12 monthsNo recordings in the last 12 months.Older appearances are listed below; set an alert to hear about the next one.
Appearances
The very day she was arrested, she had documents, mail, gift cards, and credit cards on her, none of which were hers. Among them was a JCPenney MasterCard belonging to Sue Mosley, along with letters meant for Mosley regarding her financial affairs. Arrested in Charlotte, Sandra was transported back to Brunswick County. In her mugshot, her expression is weary.
Her long dark hair is unkempt, framing her face in uneven strands. Shadows cast under her eyes give the impression of exhaustion. There's no hint of charm, no trace of the manipulative confidence that let her slip away so many times before. Just a woman caught, facing consequences at last. It was time to get this new inmate booked.
And the person in charge of that, let's just say, had been eager to meet her.
Detective Todd just watched her, scoping her out.
She was just starting to let it sink in. She wasn't in control anymore.
Again, she resisted. This woman really thought she was impervious to the law. But that's not how it works in jail. She forked it over to Detective Todd.
When Sandra was a young woman, she wanted to marry rich and have a man provide for her. But now in her 60s, she seemed to want Jesus Christ himself to provide her with a ritzy life.
Detective Todd was looking for anything, as much evidence as possible, to keep Sandra in jail as long as possible. These bizarre Bible collages weren't going to cut it.
She couldn't believe it. Receipts, camera footage, witnesses. And this woman was just going to get away with it on a technicality? Here's the thing. Despite everything Detective Todd had on Sandra, all the proof of the check and credit card fraud, this was her first offense. It was her only recorded criminal act. For a DA, going forward with a case like that was a waste of resources.
It made more sense to just put her on probation and get her to pay restitution.
If she wanted to prevent Sandra from being released and get her on a federal charge, she'd have to find more value. At least $2,500. She was $80.43 short. Once Sandra was in her jail cell, Jim was able to do some more snooping around his mom's home.
Sue had been set up nicely by her late husband's estate. It didn't make sense she'd be missing mortgage payments. Plus, Jim had already set up automatic withdrawal from her account so she wouldn't have to think about that sort of thing.
or essentially her mortgage bill, sent monthly.
Jim wrote a check for six back payments plus a $500 late fee. But he still didn't know where that money had gone. But he had an idea. If Sandra had managed to steal that money, and it could be proven, that would certainly get Detective Todd over that $2,500 hurdle. Everything was coming together for Detective Todd's case.
And it paid off. Detective Todd had compiled enough evidence to get the magic number.
Sue Mosley's mail diverted to Rock Hill. That's where Sandra had first landed in South Carolina. When she was living with Audrey, she struck up a friendship with her other caretaker. It was her address that these documents were diverted to.
Then, Detective Todd realized she had the goods on Sandra this whole time. Remember that whole she said, she said between Nancy and Sandra about the Social Security payments?
By December 2007, almost 22 years to the day after Alan Rarig was found murdered, a final indictment came for Sandra. Not for the mysterious deaths in her past. Not for the suspicions that had followed her for decades. But for three counts of bank fraud. One count of possession of stolen mail. One count of aggravated identity theft.
The bombshell who once capitalized off her elegant wardrobe could be spending up to 15 years in an orange jumpsuit. She would be headed to a federal women's prison without a man in sight that she could sink her teeth into. Next time on the finale of Fatal Beauty, Sue Mosley gets to speak her truth.
And one detective gets the interview we've all been waiting for ever since Alan Rarig's murder.
Showing 81–100 of 103 · page 5 of 6
← Previous
Next →