Keith Morrison

And I didn't want to arrest him in front of his kids.

It's something we just don't like to do.

And so we kept the surveillance up, and on a given morning, he left by himself.

And we took him down to a traffic stop and was ordered out at gunpoint by the uniformed deputies.

And his statement to them was,

I've been in Iraq.

Is this about Michelle O'Keefe?

By this time, it was personal for Longshore.

All those years going through boxes of evidence, poring over crime scene photographs of Michelle's body slumped in her blue Mustang in the dead of night.

And now, finally, he had his man.

But not all the answers, not yet.

One puzzle in particular had been bugging him.

The gun.

Michelle was shot to death.

So Jennings must have fired that gun.

And yet he'd sworn over and over that he wasn't carrying that night.

Security company rules didn't allow it.

But Longshore had done a little research, discovered Jennings was no stranger to guns.

So in the jail's interview room... I asked him about carrying a gun.

He carried a gun all the time in North Carolina.