Kendall Rae

And investigators felt wary of him right away.

And listen to how creepy this is.

When word got out that Quake could have possibly been the last person to see Sidney, Maggie actually confronted him about it.

Very brave.

And she didn't do it in an aggressive way by any means.

She just wanted to ask him directly what he saw.

Well, all he told her was that, yes, he saw her running, but that was it.

That's all he saw.

And then he gave her a hug and said, I hope you find her.

And this all happened at the command post.

And Maggie said that the second the interaction was over, she had a sinking feeling that he knew more than what he was saying.

And the following day, on the 21st,

That proved to be true.

Now, once Quake's adoptive dad got word that Quake was the last person to see her, he ended up reaching out to law enforcement himself.

And he basically was like, why don't I bring him in?

We'll come sit down for a formal interview and you guys can talk to him and see that he's innocent.

And the investigators and the sheriff were like, absolutely, come on in, let's settle this.

So they went in and at first he stuck to the same story that he saw Sidney running and nothing else.

And then he consented to letting them search his truck, which I'm sure had him shitting bricks.

Because as soon as they examined it, it was obvious that his car was involved in Sidney's disappearance.