Larry McNabney (Victim)

Lisa wanted to be known throughout the horse show circuit.

If you've been injured in an accident, call me.

I'm Larry McNabney.

The McNabney's put out a Help Wanted ad for an office assistant, and in comes a young woman who would dramatically change their lives.

She's an art student from Sacramento State University named Sarah Dutra.

Alisa interviewed Sarah for the job, and they formed a quick, close connection.

In her yearbook, Sarah Dutra was a bright, cheerful-looking student at Vacaville High School in the 90s.

She was a real go-getter, somebody that you knew was very driven.

President of her senior class was an athlete.

Her teacher spoke well of her.

Young men were enamored of her.

Sarah was super smart, tall, blonde, cute, you know, the girl you wanted to know.

Elisa, I think, saw something of herself in Sarah.

They hit it off from the beginning.

Pretty soon, inseparable friends.

They'd go out to restaurants together.

They did a lot of shopping.

Elisa's daughter Haley, who was 15 at the time, resented her mom's new best friend.

My mom would say, well, we have fun.

And I said, okay, well, can you not spend time with me like that?