Larry McNabney (Victim)

I thought, we're going to slide off the road and we're going to die.

Haley says after driving 22 hours straight from Arizona, her mother dozed off at the wheel and the car swerved.

She was startled awake by a police siren pulling them over.

from the possibility of your mom going to jail, that's the most terrifying thing you can see.

Haley says her mom apologized, and she worked her charm enough for the officer to let them go, no questions asked.

So it kind of became Mr. Toad's Wild Ride after that.

It was a two-week drive, and she kept going to these tourist locations like Denver, New Orleans, Mobile.

She's explaining to me why it's easy to disappear into a town that's based on tourism.

Meanwhile, investigators take a deep dive into Elisa McNabney's background, and they make a startling discovery.

Elisa isn't who they think she is.

Her real name is Loren Sims.

From the police perspective, at first they didn't know who the criminal was, and they sure didn't know who Loren Sims was.

The person we know as Elisa McNabney, she's used at least 11 different names.

You finally discovered her rap sheet.

How long was it?

113 pages long.

113 pages.

They found the mother of two had a rap sheet.

for bad checks and theft going back to 1987, plus outstanding warrants after skipping town on that felony probation for those Christmas presents she took all those years ago.

Remember, she thought doing that would help her boyfriend see his kids.