M. William Phelps

She told you you need to go get my books at the house?

That statement, I think, tells us Kyle knew exactly why he was headed to Dr. Schwartz's house on the night of December 8th.

Mike Fole was easy prey for investigators.

All they had to do was keep a boot on his throat, dangle life behind bars, or possibly, with the potential murder for hire aspect now involved, a death sentence.

If they did all of that, Mike would tell them everything.

Kyle explained to investigators that he told Mike Clara had instructed him to go to the house to grab her notebooks.

Mike instead told Locke he was fully aware of what was about to go down, putting it into kind of a bizarre, almost childish manner, telling Locke, Kyle went up to Schwartz's house.

I stayed outside the house and prayed for Mr. Schwartz's soul to go to heaven.

You can only get to heaven if you're dead.

Mike knew.

It's raining as they head to Schwartz's house in Mike's car.

Important to note, I think, is that Clara is at James Madison University in her dorm alone.

Katie, riding shotgun with Mike driving and Kyle in the backseat, approach Schwartz's driveway.

Kyle tells Mike to stop.

It's a long driveway.

Kyle insists Mike and Katie wait inside the car there near the road.

I'll walk the rest of the way, he tells them.

As Kyle sits with his hand on the door handle, preparing to step out and walk down the driveway, his mind races.

Kyle claims several voices return in this moment.

Voices now sending him warnings.