MatPat

He decides to distract himself with some journaling, but he notices it's brand new.

Frank's memory is continuing to fail him and it haunts him, with his thoughts becoming more aggressive, calling him an idiot, telling him no one would read his journal.

But it's almost like it's not him speaking.

Like him falling into the void beneath home in the previous video allowed home to enter his mind and speak to him, twisting his thoughts.

All of this culminates with Frank opening his door only to find a red letter on his doorstep, which he looks horrified at.

And this is where everything began to fit into place for me.

This isn't the first time we've seen this letter.

During the WHRP's Playfellow exhibition of show memorabilia, there was a secret page that contained this picture.

Frank holding a red card with a look of fear on his face.

We've speculated about this image for a while,

Notice how Frank has human hands?

This led us down the path that Frank wasn't what he seemed.

Like he was a human in a world of puppets, trying to infiltrate the neighborhood.

However, with all of this new context, I believe we're being told something similar, but slightly different.

Frank is definitely the odd one out in the group, but not because he knows too much, but more because he's breaking the rules of the show itself.

In the play, he won't kiss Julie, despite that being what he's supposed to do.

He not only knows and talks about Poppy's bong, but he's unshocked by it, meaning he's witnessed it before and maybe even partook himself.

which is not part of his character.

He left Homewarming when Wally told him not to, and he dug up Julie's flower.

He even taught Home to use Morse code so that they could communicate, when Home is supposed to be Wally's main friend.