Matt Walsh

It was him trying to move him off his seat, a soft shove.

Prosecutor, what did Austin do?

Witness, I see the hole in his chest and bloody starts screaming for help.

Prosecutor, when this is going on, who's standing?

Witness, before the stab, Austin was the one standing.

Prosecutor, did any kids from Memorial try to gang up on Carmelo?

Witness, no.

Prosecutor, you're expecting at most a fist fight.

Witness, yes.

Prosecutor, you didn't think anything was going to happen.

Witness, no.

Now, the key testimony there is that this was a soft shove, and no one expected anything more than that.

No one thought Metcalf was going to pummel Anthony, and no one thought Anthony was going to stab Metcalf.

Again, Metcalf was just trying to move the guy off the seat, get him out of the tent where he didn't belong.

Another witness described the shove as somewhere between soft and hard, so moderate, in other words.

Additionally, as reported by Brianna Morella, one witness who's black testified that he was sitting right next to Anthony at the time of the shove.

And according to the witness, the shove was so light that Carmelo wasn't even pushed into contact with him.

So this was not a violent altercation at all.

Anthony barely moved.

So that's the extent of the damage that Metcalfe did.