Menu
Sign In Search Podcasts Charts People & Topics Add Podcast API Blog Pricing

Maureen Groppe

๐Ÿ‘ค Speaker
334 total appearances

Appearances Over Time

Podcast Appearances

The Excerpt
Supreme Court hears high-stakes birthright citizenship case

whether there are any good statistics on how often this occurs, because this has been one of the president's lead arguments for why his executive order is needed.

The Excerpt
Supreme Court hears high-stakes birthright citizenship case

He's talked about many people coming to this country just to have babies here and the security risks that that poses.

The Excerpt
Supreme Court hears high-stakes birthright citizenship case

The Solicitor General acknowledged that there aren't good figures on how often this happens.

The Excerpt
Supreme Court hears high-stakes birthright citizenship case

And the Chief Justice followed up to basically say, but you agree with me, right, that we're not supposed to consider policy decisions like that, just the legal issues.

The Excerpt
Supreme Court hears high-stakes birthright citizenship case

And that question about whether policy factors should be a consideration was also raised by another of the conservative justices whose vote could be key to this decision.

The Excerpt
Supreme Court hears high-stakes birthright citizenship case

That's Justice Brett Kavanaugh.

The Excerpt
Supreme Court hears high-stakes birthright citizenship case

And he made the same point when talking about the administration's point that the United States is fairly unique.

The Excerpt
Supreme Court hears high-stakes birthright citizenship case

There are other countries that have birthright citizenship, but it's the minority.

The Excerpt
Supreme Court hears high-stakes birthright citizenship case

And Justice Kavanaugh said, well, you know, you raised that point, but that's a policy issue.

The Excerpt
Supreme Court hears high-stakes birthright citizenship case

And, you know, we're supposed to be focused on legal issues.

The Excerpt
Supreme Court hears high-stakes birthright citizenship case

Yeah, there were very many amicus briefs filed in this case.

The Excerpt
Supreme Court hears high-stakes birthright citizenship case

This case generated among the most, if not the most, this term.

The Excerpt
Supreme Court hears high-stakes birthright citizenship case

More of the briefs cited against Trump than with him.

The Excerpt
Supreme Court hears high-stakes birthright citizenship case

And the brief you're referring to was filed by Democratic members of Congress.

The Excerpt
Supreme Court hears high-stakes birthright citizenship case

There were some Republican members of Congress who filed briefs supporting Trump, but not as many Republicans waited on this as did Democrats in Congress.

The Excerpt
Supreme Court hears high-stakes birthright citizenship case

My colleague, Carissa Waddock, she was there in the courtroom just to keep an eye on that very thing.

The Excerpt
Supreme Court hears high-stakes birthright citizenship case

And she said that the president was a quiet presence in the courtroom.

The Excerpt
Supreme Court hears high-stakes birthright citizenship case

She said that there were some stifled gasps when he walked in, but other than that, his attendance was barely acknowledged by lawyers or the justices in the courtroom on Wednesday.

The Excerpt
Supreme Court hears high-stakes birthright citizenship case

He did not end up staying for the full two hours.

The Excerpt
Supreme Court hears high-stakes birthright citizenship case

He left the courtroom shortly after the justices had finished questioning the Justice Department attorney.