Melissa Jeltsin

Later that day, Greg drives over to Talena and Corey's.

Later that day, Greg drives over to Talena and Corey's.

Greg loads his trailer with the metal bed frame and heads towards the recycling center.

Greg loads his trailer with the metal bed frame and heads towards the recycling center.

I mean, it was just really, really weird things were happening. This is Rachel, another Wagner friend of Talena's.

I mean, it was just really, really weird things were happening. This is Rachel, another Wagner friend of Talena's.

There's a pretty big group of people in Wagner looking for Talena now. Rachel, Aris, Greg and his wife, Marty, a.k.a. Wolfie, and his wife Lori, as well as other neighbors, even Talena's hairdresser, Kim. They put up flyers and organize a vigil.

There's a pretty big group of people in Wagner looking for Talena now. Rachel, Aris, Greg and his wife, Marty, a.k.a. Wolfie, and his wife Lori, as well as other neighbors, even Talena's hairdresser, Kim. They put up flyers and organize a vigil.

The thing about Corey is she's a recent transplant. She's been living with Talena for less than a year. And the Wagner friends, they start to have the same nagging feeling. How well did any of them really know her?

The thing about Corey is she's a recent transplant. She's been living with Talena for less than a year. And the Wagner friends, they start to have the same nagging feeling. How well did any of them really know her?

There was really only one person in town who had a longstanding relationship with Corey. That was Marty Wolfie. They'd met more than a decade earlier at Gorefest.

There was really only one person in town who had a longstanding relationship with Corey. That was Marty Wolfie. They'd met more than a decade earlier at Gorefest.

With suspicions raised, Eris looks back over her text messages with Talena before she disappeared. And she starts to think, some of these messages don't sound like Talena. Talena had reached out to Eris on March 28th and asked her to swing by for the mattress. But at the last minute, Talena canceled.

With suspicions raised, Eris looks back over her text messages with Talena before she disappeared. And she starts to think, some of these messages don't sound like Talena. Talena had reached out to Eris on March 28th and asked her to swing by for the mattress. But at the last minute, Talena canceled.

A number of Talena's friends are also questioning the legitimacy of Talena's final Facebook post. Like Rachel, who was skeptical about it from the moment she read it.

A number of Talena's friends are also questioning the legitimacy of Talena's final Facebook post. Like Rachel, who was skeptical about it from the moment she read it.

Talena's friends in Wagner are growing distrustful of Corey, and so are the online sleuths.

Talena's friends in Wagner are growing distrustful of Corey, and so are the online sleuths.

According to the documents they can access, six years earlier, Corey was arrested and charged in Madison, Wisconsin, for using someone else's credit card.

According to the documents they can access, six years earlier, Corey was arrested and charged in Madison, Wisconsin, for using someone else's credit card.