Mr. Ballin

And he immediately asked Keith, like, what was Tabitha doing there at the strip club?

But Keith just shrugged and said, Tabitha had a wild side.

She was a regular there.

Sienna was still sort of taken aback by this and really didn't know what to think of it.

But he just told Keith to keep telling his story.

And so Keith continued and he explained how he and Tabitha had exchanged numbers that first night and then started texting and calling and how that eventually turned into regular meetups.

when Kevin was at work.

He said by July, they were hanging out several times a week and speaking on the phone basically every day.

And Keith said this continued right up until Tabitha's death.

And here, Sienna had to stop Keith again because Kevin had told Sienna that Tabitha and Keith, their affair was over.

But here Keith was basically telling Sienna the opposite.

And so when Sienna pressed him on it, Keith said that actually Tabitha had called him around 11 p.m.

on Sunday night, only about an hour before she was killed.

And so this timing just felt like way too big of a coincidence.

And it made Sienna wonder if Keith was actually just trying to give himself an alibi.

Except it was not a very good one because Keith lived close enough to Tabitha and Kevin that after that last phone call at about 11 o'clock,

he would have had time to hang up the phone and drive over to their house and commit the murder by midnight.

So this really wasn't an alibi.

So now, Sienna realized he was in a tough spot here.

Tabitha's affair really gave both Kevin and Keith strong motives to want to kill her.