Narrator/Host

What he specifically said is, are y'all looking for a blonde girl?

It had been four days since Lieutenant Holly James had vanished, and at this point, John Wymonk has emerged as the prime suspect in the disappearance of his wife, a fact not lost on his commanding officer, Colonel Kirk Cordova.

The prime suspect was a Marine, and it was one of my Marines.

And given the reputation that he had, did you think at that time that maybe he is somebody that could be guilty of this?

Yes, given his nature and the fact that he is somewhat of a hothead and wanted to be in control all the time.

As soon as I heard Wymock was our prime suspect, I assigned somebody to him and make sure he didn't leave, didn't run.

So we knew where he was at at all times.

While investigators methodically build their case against Wymock, Jesse James decides to take a more direct approach, confronting him in person.

What did he say exactly to you?

I drove out to Camp Lejeune.

And he was with, like, three friends.

I saw some arrogance.

I saw that he was drinking.

I just leaned into him very, very close.

And I said, John, if you somehow committed a perfect murder and left no evidence behind, and no one but you knows it, there's a sliver of chance that you could get away with it.

But I said, if one person knows, you're going to die for the crime.

What did you read in his face?

Fear.

Fear that all the arrogance was gone.

Police continue to try and chip away at Wymonk's fellow Marine, Kyle Alden.